‘Charlie Chopra & The Mystery of Solang Valley’ series review: An elementary whodunit

Wamiqa Gabbi in ‘Charlie Chopra & The Mystery of Solang Valley’

Embarking on his first Agatha Christie adaptation, director Vishal Bhardwaj has skipped the same old suspects — and detectives — and settled on The Sittaford Mystery, a shivery, snowbound story from 1931. The e-book’s one-off heroine, the nippy and likable Miss Emily Trefusis, offered a ripe alternative for Bhardwaj and lead actor Wamiqa Gabbi. Unburdened by the cultural ubiquity of a Poirot or a Miss Marple, they might take the character anyplace they happy; even make her a foulmouthed Punjabi woman in a beanie who steadily addresses the display screen. And but, this want for eccentric invention turns into a roadblock for Charlie Chopra & The Mystery of Solang Valley.

Before we meet Charlie, we’re launched to some of her suspects. On a stormy night evocatively shot by cinematographer Tassaduq Hussain, a number of individuals huddle inside a cottage, watching a séance. A spirit named ‘Lady Rose’ is outwardly summoned; she, in flip, signifies the demise of one Brigadier Rawat (Gulshan Grover). Though the visitors appear to brush it off, one twitchy character decides to trudge all the way down to Manali — a number of kilometers away — and examine on his previous pal. His instincts show proper: the moneyed brigadier is discovered slain in his house. The cops swiftly arrest Jimmy, the ex-armyman’s nephew who had visited him earlier within the day, the improbability of Vivaan Shah enjoying a cold-blooded assassin clearly misplaced on the Manali pressure.

Also Read | ‘If I am not a leftist, I am not an artist’: Vishal Bhardwaj

Particularly satisfied of Jimmy’s innocence is his fiancée, Charulata aka Charlie. She is an newbie sleuth (in a candy element, it was her mom, Patiala’s fearsome Dolly Chopra, who was the skilled). Arriving posthaste in Manali, Charlie reveals an online of secrets and techniques and lies, motives and cash issues. Turns out, mustachioed Rawat was forsaking a big property and everybody, together with his closest family, needed a bit. Kenneth Branagh with his recent Poirot films has revived curiosity within the all-star Christie adaptation. Bhardwaj takes a unique, barely arthouse path to this pattern: along with the whole Shah household — Vivaan, Naseer, Ratna Pathak, Imaad, Heeba — we get Lara Dutta as one of Rawat’s secretive tenants, and Priyanshu Painyuli as a streetsmart reporter who groups up with Charlie.

Wamiqa Gabbi is one of essentially the most thrilling actors working in present Hindi cinema. She’s received wit and attraction — and a prettiness that isn’t standard-issue Bollywood. She was striking in Jubilee, enjoying an actress within the 1940s and 50s, but additionally sweetly memorable within the Vishal Bhardwaj phase in Modern Love: Mumbai. The actor and director have cast an exhilarating artistic partnership — they’ve Khufiya developing subsequent week — and whereas Charlie might not be essentially the most compelling protagonist on paper, Gabbi peeps and probes with aptitude and self-possession. There is, nevertheless, one deadly snag.

Now after which, Charlie trains her hazel-brown eyes on the digital camera and talks on to the viewers. It is a blatant steal of Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s impressed fourth-wall-breaking within the two seasons of Fleabag. Here, it’s not so creative, Charlie’s remarks neither slicing nor revealing in a particular, privileging manner. They work as an occasional exclamation mark — “What even…?!”, Gabbi blinks on a number of events — however principally register as a gimmick. Also, what’s the purpose of getting inside a detective’s head when the enjoyable lies in staying on the skin, observing and attempting to work out their each transfer?

Bhardwaj and his co-writers draw out the suspense with a series of reveals and pink herrings. Episodes flit from character to character; the method of elimination — as soon as we latch on to it — leaves out solely a handful of suspects to cost. It is a quite normal, elementary manner of designing a whodunit. As in his Shakespeare movies, although, Bhardwaj finds attention-grabbing methods to Indianise the fabric. Charlie’s introductory scene is at a brash Punjabi marriage ceremony, the place she gamely tracks down the groom’s stolen sneakers (discover the motif of implicating footwear). A sub-plot resolves itself by means of information of the 1966 thriller Teesri Manzil. Elsewhere, a reference to Hindustani classical music is adopted, funnily and inevitably, with a demise by tabla.

Charlie’s credo, introduced with a assured head bobble, goes: “Case jinna mushkil, fees unni katt.” Memorable feminine detectives are skinny on the bottom in Hindi movies and exhibits. Vidya Balan has performed just a few through the years — most not too long ago in Neeyat ­— however none have yielded or deserved a franchise. If future seasons are made, Bhardwaj and Gabbi stand an opportunity to vary the sport. Just drop the Fleabag.

Charlie Chopra & The Mystery of Solang Valley is at the moment streaming on SonyLIV