A fast on-line search led to many hair dryer choices on the two acquainted e-tailing platforms, Amazon and Flipkart. But to his shock, Blinkit, recognized for delivering groceries, additionally popped up. What caught his consideration most was the price ticket—on Blinkit, a selected model of hair dryer, promoting for ₹999, was a tad cheaper when in comparison with the different on-line shops. While velocity wasn’t a prime precedence, the swift supply didn’t damage.
“Within minutes, I had the hair dryer in hand, together with some financial savings,” mentioned Sanjith.
Blinkit, owned by Zomato, is a fast commerce firm. So are Swiggy Instamart and Zepto. They largely ship items to our properties tremendous fast, inside 15-20 minutes. These firms have arrange darkish shops or micro-fulfillment centres throughout many neighbourhoods in a metropolis to facilitate the stocking, packing and quick dispatch of orders. Convenience-loving millennials in India’s giant cities have lapped up their providers—the gross merchandise worth (GMV) of fast commerce, or the worth of all items bought, have jumped from a negligible $0.1 billion in 2020 to $2.8 billion in 2023, in line with estimates by Redseer, an advisory agency.
All fast commerce firms began with groceries, or by promoting stuff corresponding to potatoes, tomatoes, mangoes, apples, rice and oil. But extra just lately, like Sanjith found, they inventory every thing from hair dryers and induction cooktops to sensible watches and dildos.
This has turn into a headache for Flipkart, one in every of India’s largest e-tailing firms with income of ₹55,823 crore in 2022-23. Selling every thing is its area. That’s what the firm, now owned by Walmart, pioneered in India for over 15 years. But this fortress is beneath risk.
Elara Capital, an funding banking agency, in a report printed in April this yr, acknowledged that fast commerce is impacting the gross sales of conventional and e-commerce firms in cities the place they are operational. “3-6% of the month-to-month FMCG (fast-moving client items)/grocery spends could transfer to fast commerce platforms led by comfort,” it acknowledged.
So, there’s an urgency inside Flipkart to launch fast commerce to guard its turf. It may launch the service inside weeks, some firm staff advised Mint. None of them wished to be recognized.
This can be the firm’s third try. In 2015, Flipkart launched a fast service referred to as Nearby to ship items inside 60 minutes. It closed down as the unit economics didn’t make sense at the moment. In 2020, the firm tried the mannequin once more with a service referred to as Flipkart Quick. It shut down for broadly the similar causes, the staff Mint spoke to mentioned.
But the fast commerce mannequin, which many trade observers wrote off even two years again, seems to be working now. “Based on what we’ve estimated, in 2024-25, fast commerce ought to have the ability to register explosive development, 70-80% or in that vary,” Kushal Bhatnagar, associate partner at Redseer, said.
According to the folks Mint spoke to, Flipkart is at present gripped by the concern of lacking out (FOMO). What can it do to capitalize on the fast commerce wave?
Flipkart didn’t reply to clarifications sought by Mint.
Early however not fast
Before delving into Flipkart’s technique, let’s first perceive what went mistaken with its earlier two endeavours.
Flipkart Nearby, launched in 2015, was a 60 minutes supply service. Flipkart Quick in 2020 promised supply in 90 minutes. Both the experiments have been largely round supply of meals, greens and different grocery gadgets.
The 2015 enterprise was a five-month pilot in Bengaluru. Flipkart was manner forward of its time—the time period ‘quick commerce’ was not in vogue again then and the thought didn’t vibe with customers, former staff mentioned.
View Full Image
In 2020, bills burdened Flipkart Quick. “The burn wasn’t making sense. There was much less site visitors on the web site, which made it much more troublesome whenever you are coping with fruits and greens,” mentioned a former worker of Flipkart Quick.
“Since there was much less site visitors, the firm was shopping for much less. When you’re shopping for much less, you don’t get the cost-benefit,” said a current employee. The company was using its existing supply chain infrastructure for logistics, the person added. “The legacy supply chain was not designed for speed. It was designed for cost optimization—we optimized a lot on the shipment cost,” he mentioned.
Flipkart Quick then struggled with stock administration.
Zepto has a weekly replenishment plan, which helps the firm preserve larger in-stock numbers and higher availability for patrons. Flipkart, on the different hand, had a day by day replenishment plan.
“On days when there was a sudden demand surge, many inventory maintaining items (SKUs) weren’t obtainable,” a former executive said. “Let’s say you order an inventory of 15 breads and someone places an order for 15 breads because of some occasion. Breads, therefore, would be out of stock for other customers,” he mentioned, including that this impacted buyer expertise.
Zepto didn’t reply to Mint’s request for a clarification.
Bigger and higher?
View Full Image
On 4 April, Albinder Dhindsa, the chief govt officer (CEO) of Blinkit, posted a brief message on X, previously Twitter. “PlayStation 5 on Blinkit. Launching tomorrow,” he wrote.
A ‘slim’ model of Sony’s newest gaming console is priced at ₹54,990. Blinkit guarantees to ship it in beneath 20 minutes.
This made product managers at Flipkart relatively nervous. “This is alarming for each Amazon and Flipkart,” one Flipkart employee said.
“The communication now’s to re-prioritize the fast commerce challenge. We have been engaged on bettering buyer expertise in regular deliveries however that isn’t a precedence now,” mentioned a present worker.
The fast commerce challenge is being led by Hemant Badri, Flipkart’s senior vp and group head of provide chain. A brand new enterprise unit has been arrange inside Flipkart with a separate know-how staff. The message—it received’t be a half-hearted try this time. “We’ve constructed larger and higher groups. And there’s infrastructure being arrange in parallel,” mentioned one other worker.
Like Blinkit, Zepto and Instamart, Flipkart can also be organising darkish shops, which is at the coronary heart of faster deliveries. It plans to prepared 1,000 such shops by the finish of June, staff quoted above knowledgeable.
Fruits and greens entice prospects. But when somebody buys electronics, it’s worthwhile.
—A Flipkart worker
What may very well be Flipkart’s differentiator?
According to a number of present staff, the firm is a bigger assortment of classes. “You will see electronics in the first launch itself,” mentioned a present worker. Electronics can also be the place Flipkart can differentiate due to the firm’s current relationships with producers and sellers, in addition to the alternative to make fatter margins.
“Fruits and greens entice prospects. But when somebody buys electronics, it’s worthwhile for the platforms. Flipkart’s wider vary goes to be a differentiator,” mentioned a present worker.
While the fast commerce infrastructure is being constructed, Flipkart is seeing a company-wide strategic change too—the whole group is shifting in the direction of a extra hyperlocal method. “We are additionally being much more related on the regular groceries entrance. Some routes in Bengaluru, for instance, are being readied for same-day deliveries and next-day deliveries,” mentioned a present govt.
Improving economics
Meanwhile, the despair round unit economics is slowly giving technique to hope. One massive lever is promoting. “Quick commerce appeals very aggressively to the FMCG sector, which is 40% of India’s promoting expenditure,” Karan Taurani, senior vp at Elara Securities, mentioned.
“With fast commerce, manufacturers can see the response of a brand new product that they’ve launched in a day,” Bhatnagar of Redseer chimed.
Second, darkish retailer efficiencies have gone up, he added. If a micro market has a major Gujarati inhabitants, for instance, fast commerce firms now inventory items favoured by the group. If a darkish retailer is ready to serve a major demand in a catchment space, the fastened prices—corresponding to rents or supply accomplice payouts—get offset, main to higher platform economics, Bhatnagar defined.
It isn’t simple
Founded in 2007 by Binny Bansal and Sachin Bansal, Flipkart began as an internet bookstore. It has historically not been a quick supply firm, with most deliveries taking up two days. This hasn’t modified over the years. It has targeted on larger warehouses as a substitute of fragmented ones. Amazon has extra fragmented warehouses, which helps it ship inside 24 hours.
The legacy enterprise of each Swiggy and Zomato, on the different hand, pivoted round quicker meals deliveries. That expertise has helped the two firms in the fast commerce enterprise. The huge overhaul of logistics that Flipkart requires to be in the fast commerce sport is due to this fact daunting.
View Full Image
“Flipkart is a extra nationwide firm. They have divided the India market into totally different cities, into totally different segments and they guarantee the proper choice and provide,” said an industry expert who didn’t want to be identified. “However, the quick commerce business requires local execution. Flipkart will have to work hard to develop and adapt to a more fast, agile model. The existing companies understand the hyperlocal play better,” the govt added.
“Companies like BigBasket began a lot earlier when in comparison with Instamart, Zepto and even Blinkit. But nonetheless, they haven’t been capable of evolve themselves when it comes to fast commerce,” Taurani mentioned.
A second problem for Flipkart can be market share. By now, companies such as Blinkit and Zepto have already created muscle reminiscence for patrons residing in cities, market watchers mentioned. When you need a fast supply, you already know these platforms are the choices.
That leaves Flipkart with the non-metros, the place it’s a dominant platform. But fast commerce is but to choose up tempo in tier 2 or tier 3 markets.
“Amazon’s transition would seemingly be extra seamless attributable to current buyer belief in buying non-essential gadgets on the platform. Flipkart, with its restricted penetration in metros, would require extra time,” Satish Meena, an impartial e-commerce analyst and advisor at Datum Intelligence, mentioned.
We must wait and watch if electronics can certainly be a differentiator. In the absence of a differentiator, Flipkart would want to low cost, harming the unit economics. While two present staff mentioned the solely differentiator may very well be a wider assortment, there’s an issue right here too. The classes that Amazon and Flipkart cope with—like electronics and trend—are discovery pushed, mentioned Meena.
Flipkart, with its restricted penetration in metros, would require extra time.
—Satish Meena
“Apart from the impulse purchases, your grocery manufacturers are nearly outlined. You don’t change your atta or your bread model. You simply repeat nearly every thing. Quick commerce firms know what SKUs are being ordered and then inventory accordingly,” he mentioned.
Growth challenge
Nonetheless, the fast commerce guess is crucial for Flipkart. Of course, it has to defend its turf. But it additionally has to develop its GMV, which, in flip, will decide the firm’s valuation. A present worker succinctly pointed it out, calling the enterprise a “development challenge”.
On 18 March, PTI, a information company, reported that the e-tailer’s valuation had taken successful. Citing transactions by its US-based guardian, Walmart, it mentioned that as of 31 January 2024, Flipkart was valued at $35 billion, down from $40 billion in 2022-23. The decline in worth was attributed to the separation of the firm’s fintech arm, PhonePe, into an impartial entity.
Kalyan Krishnamurthy, the Flipkart group’s CEO, has communicated to staff on a number of events about his want to take the firm public “after reaching a sure valuation”. We don’t know what that number is but there is definitely a lot at stake for the e-tailer’s quick commerce venture.