20 Beloved Fast Food Items We Wish Would Make a Comeback – Chowhound’s Ultimate Nostalgia List!

Nostalgia is a powerful force, especially for millennials. As adults, we often crave the comforts of our youth, from fashion trends like baggy jeans to pop culture revivals like Backstreet Boys reunions. This longing also extends to fast food. Many of us fondly remember our favorite discontinued menu items. Who knows? Some may even make a comeback, much like the beloved McRib or McDonald’s Snack Wrap.

Let’s explore some of the fast food items from our past that still make our mouths water.

Mexi-Nuggets from Taco Bell

For West Coast kids, Taco Bell’s Mexi-Nuggets were a go-to side. These crispy, potato nuggets were replaced by the less exciting Fiesta Potatoes in 2004. A Facebook petition still exists, with about 700 signatures, asking Taco Bell to bring Mexi-Nuggets back. If you’re craving something similar, Taco John’s Potato Olés or Taco Time’s Mexi Fries might satisfy, though nothing quite matches the original.

Popcorn Chicken from KFC

KFC’s Popcorn Chicken made its debut in 1992 but was removed from menus in 2023. These small, tasty bites were perfect for dipping in sauces. Interestingly, Popeyes also discontinued a similar version, highlighting a trend where bite-sized chicken snacks have fallen out of favor.

Coffee Toffee Twisted Frosty from Wendy’s

This delightful mocha-like treat was available from 2009 to 2011. Although Wendy’s has other flavors, none have quite matched the magic of the Coffee Toffee Twisted Frosty. Given the brand’s recent interest in seasonal flavors, there’s potential for a return.

Quesarito from Taco Bell

The Quesarito, a delicious blend of a burrito and a quesadilla, was pulled from menus in 2023, despite a petition gathering about 400 signatures for its return. Fans loved its cheesy filling and convenient packaging, and many still hope for its comeback.

Fish McBites from McDonald’s

Though short-lived, McDonald’s Fish McBites were a catchy idea that proved unpopular, lasting only three months in 2013. Despite their cute packaging and a catchy jingle, they faded into obscurity, showing that not all innovations meet consumer approval.

Bucket of Spaghetti from Little Caesar’s

Once available in a hand-held bucket, this spagetti dish might have been a mess, but it has a certain charm. Although it vanished in the ’90s, many fans still recall it fondly, making it a candidate for a quirky revival.

McSalad Shakers from McDonald’s

In 2000, McDonald’s tried introducing a “shake your salad” idea with McSalad Shakers. Unfortunately, the concept vanished in 2003 as traditional salads took over, perhaps too ambitious for its time before portable meals became more popular.

Asian Salad from Chick-fil-A

Chick-fil-A’s Asian Salad was a hit with its mix of greens, chicken, and almonds. Discontinued in 2016, it still has fans hoping for its return as the chain focuses on fewer salad options.

Plum Sauce from Panda Express

This beloved condiment, gone since 2022, had fans craving its fruity kick. Social media outcry highlights the strong emotional connection to even the smallest menu items, showing that changes can stir significant backlash.

Fried Mac ‘N Cheese Bites from Arby’s

These comfort food bites had a brief return in limited markets in 2024 but have since disappeared again. With their creamy, fried goodness, it’s no wonder fans want them back.

Cini Minis from Burger King

A 1998 breakfast offering, Cini Minis were tiny, sweet cinnamon rolls. Though they returned in a couple of Florida locations, there’s still no word on a nationwide comeback, leaving many fans yearning for their sweet nostalgia.

Sriracha Curly Fry Burger from Jack in the Box

This quirky burger made waves in 2014 but was removed from menus in 2023. The combination of flavors captured a moment in time when Sriracha was at its peak popularity, leaving a unique legacy.

Hot Dog Bites Pizza from Pizza Hut

Introduced in 2015, this bizarre yet intriguing pizza with hot dogs in the crust had a limited run. While it was more gimmicky than practical, the idea was fun, and many still hope for its return.

These delicious memories remind us that fast food menus are a constantly shifting landscape. As we look to the future, here’s hoping some of these culinary gems will make a comeback!