2025 NFL Mock Draft: Expert College Football Writers Share Their Predictions for the Top First-Round Picks

The NFL Draft season is buzzing, and the 2025 NFL Combine is where it all begins. College stars are getting evaluated as teams look to build their futures. The Athletic’s team of college football experts is breaking down the top prospects and offering insights on who these players might become in the professional league.

Here’s a look at their mock draft predictions:

1. Tennessee Titans: Cam Ward, QB, Miami

The Titans have a choice between Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders. Ward stands out with impressive skills and a strong performance at Washington State and Miami. His ability to read the game and athleticism make him a top pick. An elite quarterback like Ward can change a team’s future. — David Ubben

2. Cleveland Browns: Abdul Carter, DE, Penn State

The Browns need a quarterback, but with uncertainty around Myles Garrett’s future, Abdul Carter is hard to overlook. Carter could become a star rusher, whether paired with Garrett or stepping into his role. — Cameron Teague Robinson

3. New York Giants: Travis Hunter, CB/WR, Colorado

Even though the Giants need a quarterback, Travis Hunter is the best talent in this draft. His playmaking abilities could elevate the team’s offense significantly. If they don’t find their quarterback next year, big names like Arch Manning might be waiting in 2026. — Grace Raynor

4. New England: Will Campbell, OT, LSU

The Patriots need to protect their quarterback, and Will Campbell is the perfect fit. Standing at 6’6″ and weighing 320 pounds, he’s been a wall against defenders, allowing minimal sacks throughout his college career. — Ubben

5. Jacksonville Jaguars: Jalon Walker, LB/Edge, Georgia

After struggling defensively last year, the Jaguars are looking to Jalon Walker, a standout linebacker. His skills in disrupting plays could make a big difference alongside former Georgia teammate Travon Walker. — Matt Baker

6. Las Vegas Raiders: Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado

The Raiders might consider a defensive pick, but they need to think long-term at quarterback. Shedeur Sanders, known for his accuracy and prolific passing, could help strengthen the team’s future. — Antonio Morales

7. New York Jets: Mason Graham, DT, Michigan

The Jets are looking to bolster their defense, and Mason Graham is a great fit. He’s one of the few players expected to come in and make an immediate impact. They need strong disruptors on the line. — Chris Kamrani

8. Carolina Panthers: Mike Green, Edge, Marshall

The Panthers had a tough time defensively last season, and Mike Green can help change that. Despite concerns about his size, his productivity at the Senior Bowl and in college shows he can compete at a high level. — Raynor

9. New Orleans Saints: Mykel Williams, Edge, Georgia

If Mykel Williams is available, the Saints should grab him. His combination of size and speed can overpower linemen, and he has the potential to be a standout player in the league. — Ubben

10. Chicago Bears: Armand Membou, OT, Missouri

With their quarterback taking too many hits last season, the Bears need to improve their offensive line. Armand Membou could step in and provide solid protection and versatility on the line. — Scott Dochterman

This mock draft provides just a glimpse into the college prospects that could reshape teams in the NFL. As the Combine unfolds, these players will showcase their skills, and more surprises are sure to come.