The recent beta of macOS Tahoe 26 stirred up some significant chatter online. Apple switched up the Finder icon in an unexpected way by flipping the dark and light sides. Instead of the classic look, the dark side ended up on the right. People didn’t like it, and many called for a return to tradition. By the second beta, Apple restored the classic design.
One designer, Stephen Hackett, voiced concerns about this change. He noted that the dark side of the Finder icon has been on the left for years. In his words, “Apple needs to roll this back.” His feedback reflected a general sentiment among users longing for consistency in design.
Stephen celebrated when Apple adjusted the icon back to its traditional format in the second beta release. He humorously described the prior design as a “14-day national nightmare.”
Yet, not everyone was satisfied. Notable writer John Gruber pointed out that while the update was an improvement, it still wasn’t perfect. He emphasized that the new design didn’t maintain an even balance. Instead, he suggested it looked like a sticker stuck to a blue tile, rather than a cohesive icon.
Designer Michael Flarup proposed his own version of the icon. He aimed to keep the desired glassy feel while restoring balance to the design. Many users on social media appreciated his take, leading to discussions about whether Apple should consider adopting it.
This debate over the Finder icon mirrors larger trends in tech design, where user feedback is crucial. As design changes happen, they often evoke strong emotions. Users expect products to evolve while retaining core elements that make them familiar and loved. The Finder icon saga serves as a reminder of how design shapes user experience.
According to a recent survey by Statista, about 70% of users prefer designs that stay true to their historical form, especially for iconic brands like Apple. This shows that while innovation is important, many users cherish classic designs and would rather see refinements than drastic changes.
The discussion around the Finder icon is ongoing. As Apple navigates user preferences, it will be interesting to see how they balance innovation with tradition in future updates.