Why Many Are Losing Faith in Carney’s Commitment to Combat the Climate Crisis

Prime Minister Mark Carney has labeled the Trump administration’s impact on international politics and economics as revolutionary. He is working hard to navigate this major shift while facing a global crisis: climate change.

According to a recent UN Environment Program (UNEP) report, if we keep going as we are, Earth could warm up by about 2.7°C by 2100. A study from top climate scientists published in Oxford Academic emphasizes that we’re on the brink of a climate disaster, noting that current conditions are unlike anything we’ve seen before.

Canadians are already feeling the effects, with severe wildfires sweeping through Western Canada. Carney is no stranger to climate risks. Back in 2015, as Governor of the Bank of England, he delivered his famous “tragedy of the horizon” speech, warning bankers about climate change’s threat to financial stability.

In his 2021 book Value(s), Carney criticizes blind faith in the free market, linking it to issues like climate change and inequality. He’s actively involved in promoting sustainable practices, such as serving on the Vatican’s Council for Inclusive Capitalism.

In an interview shortly after becoming the UN Special Envoy for Climate Action and Finance in December 2019, Carney declared climate change the greatest existential threat we face and urged the public to advocate for immediate action.

Canada’s Climate Goals

Canada has pledged to cut its greenhouse gas emissions by 45 to 50% from 2005 levels by 2035, building on a target of 40 to 45% by 2030. However, a report from Canada’s Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development reveals that emissions have only decreased by 7.1% since 2005. This is far from the ambitious targets set under the Paris Agreement.

Additionally, Canadian banks are still heavily investing in fossil fuel projects. The Net-Zero Banking Alliance, an initiative aimed at supporting climate action, has lost over 140 banks, including major Canadian banks, since the Trump administration’s era.

Actions Under Carney’s Leadership

In his victory speech, Carney called for an industrial strategy that balances competitiveness with climate action. He has appointed Tim Hodgson, a former banker with ties to the fossil fuel industry, as the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources.

Interestingly, Hodgson has pushed for carbon-capture projects in Alberta’s oil sands but faces skepticism about the feasibility of these technologies. A report from Oxford University cautions against relying heavily on carbon capture to offset fossil fuel use, suggesting it could lead to economic harm.

Carney’s cabinet appears to be focused more on energy strategy than on clear-cut climate policies. His mandate letter to cabinet insisted that the government work urgently to tap into Canadian resources while somewhat vaguely stating, “We will fight climate change.”

This approach has led to criticism, especially around the introduction of Bill C-5, which could allow the government to bypass environmental laws for resource projects. Environmental groups worry this could compromise laws that protect ecosystems and Indigenous rights.

A Balancing Act for the Future

Carney’s deep understanding of climate issues raises concerns about his current direction. Will he take the necessary steps to meet Canada’s Paris Agreement commitments? How will he adjust fossil fuel emission caps or the clean electricity investment plan?

Without significant changes, hopes for meaningful climate action may waver.

Bruce Campbell, an expert on environmental policy and former executive director of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, reflects a growing sentiment: optimism is thin, and tough choices lie ahead.

For further reading on Canada’s climate commitments and actions, you can refer to the UNEP and Oxford Academic.

Source link