When the Steelers meet the Panthers for the 2025 preseason finale, starting quarterback Aaron Rodgers won’t be on the field. This is unusual since it’s the first time in nearly two decades that a healthy Steelers’ starting QB hasn’t played during the preseason.
As reported by Gerry Dulac from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, this marks a significant shift for the team, which has always valued preseason play for starters. The situation raises some questions about the strategy behind it.
Rodgers and coach Mike Tomlin likely had a conversation about their plan when Rodgers visited the team facility in March. They might have agreed that Rodgers would oficially join the team before the mandatory minicamp in June. This allows him to skip earlier practices without raising eyebrows. It’s also probable they deliberated on not having him play any preseason games.
Rodgers, with his experience and skill, has leverage here. The Steelers needed a strong quarterback as they aim to snag their first playoff win since 2016. It makes sense that Rodgers would clarify expectations before signing on.
Regardless, he’ll step onto the field as a Steelers player in the opening week against the Jets—his former team. This matchup is unique as Rodgers has never faced a former team in the NFL, making it a thrilling spectacle, especially in Jet’s territory where fans will be eagerly watching.
Yet, skipping the preseason raises concerns about preparation. Since Rodgers hasn’t played, the first games could be challenging. The first three matchups against the Jets, Seahawks, and Patriots seem promising, but the schedule gets tougher afterwards with games against the Vikings, Bengals, Ravens, and more.
Winning early is crucial. Losing even once could create unnecessary pressure. The margins for playoff positions are slim, especially in a competitive AFC.
Choosing not to play Rodgers in the preseason is a gamble. If the Steelers stumble out of the gate, fans may question whether a few snaps in preseason could have changed the outcome. The stakes are high, and all eyes will be on Rodgers to see if this unconventional approach pays off.
