A bakery in New Jersey is dishing out what many consider the best cake slice in the state. Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery in Rutherford garnered this title thanks to its delicious citrus olive oil cake. According to the popular site Tasting Table, this cake features a citrus-vanilla glaze that strikes a perfect balance between tart and sweet. It’s a treat that’s sure to brighten anyone’s day.
Owner Renee Faris opened Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery in 2015. Since then, it has become well-loved in the community, earning spots on NJ.com’s lists of top bakeries and best doughnuts. Their sweet potato cayenne biscuits and Olympic muffins have also captured hearts (and taste buds).
Tasting Table chose these often-coveted spots based on awards, chef accolades, and rave reviews from the public. Most featured bakeries allow customers to grab a slice of cake or a small version of it, like petite gâteau.
Erie’s success reflects a broader trend. According to a recent survey by the National Bakery Association, nearly 80% of Americans enjoy visiting local bakeries regularly. People love the connection to their community and the personal touch that local businesses offer, especially during uncertain times.
Besides Erie, other standout desserts on the list include Freed’s Bakery’s cake and pastry flight from Nevada and Prantl’s Bakery’s famous burnt almond torte from Pennsylvania. Each of these places brings something unique to the table.
As tastes evolve and people become more adventurous, bakeries are finding new ways to engage with customers. Food trends continue to shift, embracing everything from classic recipes to modern flavors.
If you’re in Rutherford, stop by Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery. It’s not just about cake; it’s about community and shared joy through food.
For more delicious insights, check out Tasting Table’s full list of best cake slices across the U.S. here.
