In the Netflix true crime documentary “The Perfect Neighbor,” we see a tragic story unfold in a quiet Ocala, Florida neighborhood. The film begins with a young girl, eight-year-old Afrika Owens, sharing her experience with her neighbor, 58-year-old Susan Lorincz. Afrika’s mother, Ajike “AJ” Owens, allowed her and her brothers to play with other children in a vacant field next door. Despite their innocent fun, Lorincz repeatedly called the police, claiming the kids were causing trouble and trespassing.
The documentary is built around police bodycam footage, giving viewers an intimate and often uncomfortable look at the situation. Through the eyes of the kids, we witness the confusion and fear they face as they become targets of an adult’s anger. This tension escalates, culminating in a horrific event on June 2, 2023. After an argument, AJ approached Lorincz’s home and was shot through the door, tragically losing her life.
The film’s choice to focus on real police footage enhances its authenticity. We see the immediate chaos that follows the shooting, revealing the emotional toll on the community and the children. One haunting moment captures AJ’s son, 12-year-old Isaac, desperately trying to help his mother, begging for someone to call 911. It’s a heart-wrenching scene that no child should have to witness.
Though “The Perfect Neighbor” is compelling, it raises questions about the limits of true crime and the portrayal of real-life suffering. The documentary sheds light on the controversial “stand your ground” laws in America, which allow deadly force in self-defense. Research shows these laws disproportionately impact Black individuals, fueling discussions on race and justice.
However, while the film highlights important issues, it can feel heavy-handed. Viewers are left grappling with the emotional aftermath, witnessing children face unimaginable loss in real-time. The film masterfully portrays the tragedy but pushes the boundaries of what is appropriate to show.
As true crime documentaries continue to rise in popularity, it’s crucial to consider the ethics behind them. The genre often walks a fine line between telling a powerful story and sensationalizing trauma. In the case of “The Perfect Neighbor,” the raw emotion and seriousness of the subject force us to confront difficult questions about morality, empathy, and the responsibility of filmmakers.
For more on the implications of “stand your ground” laws, check out this recent report from the American Bar Association.
