After Zohran Mamdani’s recent rise as a major progressive figure in New York City politics, his campaign sparked a lively debate over his ambitious proposals. Critics have dismissed ideas like free bus service, universal childcare, and rent freezes as unrealistic and too costly.
However, supporters argue that these ideas are common in many parts of the world. Dutch environmentalist Alexander Verbeek pointed out that while Europeans see such services as normal, Americans often view them as radical. He mentioned that people in Europe expect their governments to provide essential services and are willing to pay higher taxes for them.
Take Tallinn, the capital of Estonia. It began offering free public transport in 2013, financed by local taxes. Initially met with skepticism, the scheme increased public transit use by 14% within a year. Other cities, like Montpellier and Dunkirk in France, have adopted similar plans, showing that affordable public transport can succeed beyond Tallinn.
Mamdani’s idea of city-run grocery stores also garners interest. Aslı Aydıntaşbaş from the Brookings Institution reflected on successful examples in Istanbul, where city-operated stores provided low-income families with essential goods. Similar initiatives are emerging in Chicago and Atlanta, demonstrating that such programs can be effective and beneficial.
Universal childcare is another key element of Mamdani’s platform. New Mexico recently became the first U.S. state to offer free childcare for all families, aiming to improve the economy and welfare of its children. Meanwhile, Portugal and Berlin have already introduced free childcare measures, prioritizing access for low-income families.
Mamdani also suggests providing new parents with a “baby basket” containing essential items—an initiative that has been successful in Finland since 1949. This program has been copied globally, emphasizing the effectiveness of supporting families early on.
Despite these progressive ideas, some U.S. critics remain skeptical. Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers criticized Mamdani’s rent freeze proposal, comparing it to destructive policies. Nonetheless, Berlin’s recent rent freeze law gave temporary relief to many residents before being overturned by the courts. Interestingly, a 2022 study showed that during the rent freeze, residents were more open to new housing developments, hinting that such policies could pave the way for increased affordable housing options.
In the past, New York City itself had instances where rent freezes were implemented under Mayor Bill de Blasio, raising questions about the legitimacy of current criticisms against Mamdani’s proposals.
Overall, Mamdani’s vision, though seen as ambitious by some, reflects a growing conversation about the role of government in meeting the needs of citizens in an evolving society.
Source link
