James L. Brooks is known for telling stories about complex women with messy lives. His latest film, “Ella McCay,” features an earnest young politician who tries to mend her family’s brokenness, which shapes her approach to politics.
Set in 2008, the film takes a step back from today’s fraught political climate, making it feel somewhat outdated. The story mirrors classic films like “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington” rather than modern narratives. Although it feels a bit chaotic, like its main character, it has a charm that makes up for its flaws.
In the film, Ella (played by Emma Mackey) is the 34-year-old lieutenant governor of New York. Her mentor, Bill (Albert Brooks), is stepping down to join the President’s cabinet, which means Ella will likely take his place. However, he believes her honest and direct nature may not win votes, even if it earns her loyal support from her Aunt Helen (Jamie Lee Curtis) and dedicated assistant, Estelle (Julie Kavner).
Flashbacks reveal Ella’s struggle to create a perfect life for her family. Her father, Eddie (Woody Harrelson), has a history of failed relationships and has just lost his job, shifting the family dynamics significantly. After their mother’s passing, Ella marries her high school boyfriend, Ryan (Jack Lowden), who might be more interested in leveraging her political career than genuinely supporting her.
As Ella becomes governor, she faces political backlash over minor infractions and her estranged father reenters her life. His motives are unclear, particularly as he brings a new girlfriend who demands reconciliation with Ella and her brother, Casey (Spike Fearn), who is brilliant yet socially anxious.
The film beautifully portrays the sibling bond between Ella and Casey. They share moments that are heartfelt and relatable, with Casey’s journey to embrace vulnerability being especially touching. He boldly says, “I’ve decided not to be normal. Pick something easier,” showcasing his thoughtful perspective as he navigates life. Their interactions emphasize the importance of understanding individual differences in relationships.
While the personal narratives shine brighter than the political themes, the film does have its shortcomings, especially toward the end, which feels rushed. Yet, the engaging dialogue, optimism, and endearing performances make “Ella McCay” worth watching. It reflects a unique blend of personal and political challenges, highlighting the resilience of its characters in a world that often demands conformity.
