The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform has released a report titled “Leadership Breakdown: How D.C.’s Police Chief Undermined Crime Data Accuracy.” This report raises serious concerns about the actions of Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) Chief Pamela A. Smith, who allegedly pressured her commanders to alter crime data to show a false sense of security regarding crime levels in Washington, D.C.
Interviews with MPD district commanders reveal a troubling environment under Chief Smith. Many spoke of fear and intimidation, with instances of retaliation against those who reported crime accurately. This situation has undoubtedly lowered morale and led to the departure of experienced officers.
Chairman James Comer remarked, “Every individual in D.C. deserves a safe city. Unfortunately, it seems the public was misled about real crime rates.” He emphasized that Smith’s alleged manipulation of statistics is dangerous and harms trust in local leadership.
The investigation began in August 2025 after whistleblower accounts indicated systemic issues within the department. Smith announced her resignation in December 2025, following mounting evidence and testimonies.
Key findings from the report include:
Pressure to Alter Data: Chief Smith reportedly demanded commanders create low crime numbers at the expense of accuracy, frequently pushing for lesser charges that wouldn’t be recorded publicly.
Effects of Federal Intervention: President Trump’s Executive Order in August 2025 aimed to address rising crime in D.C. by placing the MPD under federal oversight. Commanders felt this move was beneficial in combating crime.
Toxic Work Environment: Testimonies indicate a culture where officers faced demotions and transfers if they reported rising crime accurately, fostering an environment of fear.
Ongoing Risks to Crime Data: Even post-resignation, crime classifications still pose a risk, as they can be manipulated to present an unrealistically positive crime rate.
Need for New Leadership: The Committee has called for D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser to appoint a new police chief who can restore integrity to crime reporting and create a more supportive environment for officers.
This situation highlights the important balance between accurate crime data and public safety. As communities seek safer environments, transparent and honest reporting from law enforcement is crucial.
For those interested in further details, you can read the full report here.
