Movie Review: The Choral
Set in 1916, The Choral takes a unique approach to the World War I story. Instead of fighting on the frontlines, it focuses on a choir back home in England. The film, written by Alan Bennett, aims to offer a touching narrative but struggles to make a lasting impact.
Ralph Fiennes plays Dr. Guthrie, the new choir conductor. His arrival is met with mixed feelings from choir members. Many disapprove, partly because of his past in Germany and suspicions about his personal life. This tension adds layers to the choir’s dynamics but isn’t fully explored.
Dr. Guthrie attempts to reshape the choir by adapting Edward Elgar’s “Dream of Gerontius” into a piece reflecting the war’s toll. Unfortunately, the film’s first hour drags on. It focuses on funerals and choir auditions without developing characters deeply. Viewers don’t get to know the young choir members well enough to care about their struggles.
The choir becomes a mix of diverse talents: wounded soldiers, a baker, and even a novice singer. One memorable line suggests that a choir should rise above societal expectations. However, scenes featuring the older committee members often feel rambling and repetitive.
Director Nicholas Hytner and cinematographer Mike Eley also make odd stylistic choices. At one point, Dr. Guthrie stares directly at the camera, breaking the viewer’s immersion.
Among the choir, two teenage boys—Ellis and Lofty—face a stark transition to adulthood as they prepare for war. Their journey includes a brief encounter that highlights their innocence. Yet, the exploration of their characters is superficial.
The climax features the choir’s performance of “Dream of Gerontius.” This segment shines due to strong vocals and impressive cinematography. However, as the film draws to a close, the emotional stakes fall flat. The audience lacks a connection to the characters, making the farewell scene with departing soldiers less impactful.
With a runtime stretching over 113 minutes, The Choral offers some bright moments—especially in its visuals and setting. Yet, it ultimately lacks the harmony it aims to convey, resulting in a muted experience.
Rating: 2.5/5 Stars.
