Sure! Here’s a more engaging and concise version of the content.
As we wrap up the 2025 MLS season, it’s time to reflect on how teams fared. I’m looking at their overall performance, including major tournaments like the Concacaf Champions Cup and both the US Open Cup and Canadian Championship. Transfers from last winter and summer, plus the introduction of young players into key roles, will factor into these evaluations.
However, I won’t consider any signings or departures made after the MLS Cup for this round of grading. Instead of traditional letter grades, I’ll mark teams as “Exceeded Expectations,” “Met Expectations,” or “Below Expectations.” Let’s go through the teams in reverse alphabetical order—just for fun!
Toronto FC struggled mightily this season. The strategy with aging players didn’t pan out. The mid-spring decision to rebuild is a step in the right direction, but it might be too late to salvage this season. They’ve got some strong players like Djordje Mihailovic and clarity from the front office for 2026.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Philadelphia Union made some bold coaching changes this year, bringing in Bradley Carnell to instill a vigorous playing style. The result? A Supporters’ Shield win and impressive player development, with talented prospects like Quinn Sullivan and Olwethu Makhanya shining. While they faced challenges in later tournament rounds, they exceeded their own goals.
Grade: Exceeded Expectations.
Orlando City showed great potential early in the season, harnessing effective play from their core players. However, they finished lower in the standings and bowed out of the playoffs early. An over-reliance on veteran players hurt their chances.
Grade: Slightly Below Expectations.
New York Red Bulls faced a tough season. Despite adding star striker Eric-Maxim Choupo-Moting, their defense lacked strength, leading to a disappointing finish, which ended their 15-year playoff streak.
Grade: Below Expectations.
NYCFC saw head coach Pascal Jansen adapting tactics to cope with injuries. While not all players shined, the team landed a solid Eastern Conference final spot, reflecting growth and adaptability.
Grade: Exceeded Expectations.
New England Revolution encountered disappointment as they continued to reshape their roster. Some players shone, but there’s uncertainty about the future direction.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Nashville SC had a standout year, winning the US Open Cup and evolving their gameplay under coach B.J. Callaghan. They still have room to improve but made strides toward a bright future.
Grade: Exceeded Expectations+.
Montreal Impact underwent several changes but failed to find their footing, finishing low in the standings after a promising 2024.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Inter Miami had an incredible season, winning the MLS Cup and leading in roster management. Having Lionel Messi undoubtedly raised their profile, and the team’s ambition is high.
Grade: Exceeded Expectations.
D.C. United faced a season to forget, with no standout performances and struggles post-mid-season coaching changes. A fresh start is necessary going into 2026.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Columbus Crew hit a wall after losing their star player, Cucho Hernández. The team struggled, and their performance dipped as they missed crucial goals and wins.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Despite spending big on new signings, FC Cincinnati failed to gel as a unit, leading to inconsistent results throughout the season.
Grade: Below Expectations.
Chicago Fire turned things around with solid coaching, achieving a playoff spot and showing promise for future success.
Grade: Exceeded Expectations.
Charlotte FC made strides but faltered in tournament play despite solid regular-season performance.
Grade: Met Expectations.
Atlanta United had a disappointing season filled with missed opportunities and struggles to find the right chemistry. A coaching change seems necessary as they look ahead.
Grade: Below Expectations.
As we look to next season, it’s clear that every team has room for growth and storytelling to carry into 2026. Each team’s journey will continue, making for an exciting narrative in the future.
For further insights on the state of MLS, check out MLS for more detailed coverage and statistics.
Source link
Armchair Analyst: Matt Doyle,Toronto FC,SendToNews,Philadelphia Union,Orlando City SC,Red Bull New York,New York City Football Club,New England Revolution,Nashville SC,CF Montréal,Inter Miami CF,D.C. United,Columbus Crew,FC Cincinnati,Chicago Fire FC,Charlotte FC,Atlanta United
