Research in Nature Sustainability reveals that certain climate policies can unintentionally backfire. These measures might make people feel like they’re being forced into compliance, which can weaken their commitment to environmental issues. Instead of fostering “green” values, they risk pushing people away.
Katrin Schmelz from the Technical University of Denmark led the study and noted, “Policies can alter people’s core values, leading to negative responses.” The research surveyed over 3,000 individuals in Germany, asking about various climate policies and comparing them to COVID-19 restrictions.
One major finding showed that lifestyle mandates, such as urban car bans, provoked strong backlash—even from those who think of themselves as eco-friendly. Interestingly, participants reacted more strongly against climate rules than pandemic restrictions, with opposition to climate measures being 52% greater.
The study describes this reaction as a “crowding-out effect.” When people feel controlled, they may become resentful, distracting them from making eco-friendly choices, like cycling or using public transport. Sam Bowles from the Santa Fe Institute, a co-author of the study, warns, “These crowding-out effects are significant and should concern policymakers.”
A surprising aspect of the study is that the pushback against climate mandates could be more intense than the reaction to COVID-19 rules. Bowles remarked, “We saw strong hostility towards controls during the pandemic. Climate policies could face even more resistance.”
Lifestyle changes often come up in climate conversations. Daily habits, such as travel and diet, significantly contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. For instance, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) estimates that meat and dairy production is responsible for about 14-15% of global emissions. Meanwhile, transportation contributes around a quarter of all energy-related carbon dioxide emissions, with private cars being a major factor.
However, researchers emphasize that this doesn’t mean governments should abandon efforts to promote sustainable habits. The IPCC estimates that changes in consumption and travel could reduce global emissions by up to 70% by 2050.
The way policies are crafted matters greatly. People were more receptive when they believed a policy would effectively reduce emissions, respected their privacy, and wasn’t perceived as directly restricting personal freedom.
In summary, finding the right balance in climate policies is crucial. Engaging the public without making them feel controlled can lead to more effective and lasting change.
Source link
Climate Change, Environment
