Costco has become a go-to shopping destination for many, and for good reason. The annual membership fee of $65 for the Gold Star Membership (or $130 for the Executive Membership) can seem steep. However, savvy shopping can quickly justify this cost. With a few key purchases, you can make the most of your membership, saving more than the fee itself.
Recently, a discussion on Reddit sparked interest about essential items that make the membership worthwhile, especially for those who don’t typically buy in bulk. Users recommended various staples, from over-the-counter medications like ibuprofen to fan-favorite rotisserie chicken. Some even claimed that indulging in smoked salmon and buying diapers could more than cover the fee.
A deeper dive into value was provided by Business Insider, which analyzed key items in relation to membership costs. The report used artificial intelligence to estimate annual usage of essential products and their savings potential. They assigned a “payback score” to each item, indicating how many times it could offset the membership fee. For example, a score of 100 means the savings equal the cost of membership.
Key findings showed that common grocery items can provide significant savings. A 38-pound bag of Blue Buffalo dog food typically costs about $111 at regular retailers, but it’s available at Costco for around $65—offering a payback score of 713. That means buying just two bags would cover your membership. Similarly, a jumbo pack of Huggies diapers is about $50 at Costco, compared to $70 elsewhere, giving it a payback score of 373.
Even popular Starbucks coffee blends show similar savings. At Costco, a bag can cost around $8.40 per pound, versus $12 at conventional retailers. Annually, the membership fee can be recouped after purchasing just 18 pounds.
However, not every item offers the same level of savings. Toilet paper, for instance, offers more modest benefits. A 30-pack of Charmin at Costco costs approximately $1.10 per roll, about 37 cents less than at other stores. This pegs its payback score at 67, illustrating that you would need to buy several packs to see real savings.
In short, Costco’s membership can pay off, especially if you focus on essential items that deliver significant savings. Many people find that their groceries and household items quickly justify the membership cost. With planning and smart shopping, your Costco membership could turn out to be a worthwhile investment.
