“America’s Next Top Model” started in May 2003, created by Tyra Banks. It combined elements of reality competition shows like “American Idol” with the social dynamics of “The Real World.” After being rejected by many networks, UPN picked it up, and surprisingly, it became a popular show targeted at younger viewers. Banks’ phrase “smize” (smiling with your eyes) became widely known, influencing fashion and pop culture. While the show didn’t launch a supermodel, it did provide exposure for talents like Winnie Harlow and Yaya DaCosta.
During the COVID-19 lockdown in 2020, the show resurfaced in discussions. Viewers watched it through a more critical lens, considering the social justice movements sparked by George Floyd’s death. Many found the judges’ harsh critiques and controversial photoshoot themes troubling, especially those involving race and body image.
In the docuseries “Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model,” Banks shares her reflections but doesn’t acknowledge the full weight of the criticism. Judges and former contestants express their conflicted feelings about the show, highlighting past instances of body shaming and racial insensitivity. For instance, Danielle Evans, the winner of Cycle 6, recalls being pressured to alter her signature gap-toothed smile to fit a beauty standard. Her story reveals how the show often exploited contestants’ vulnerabilities, offering scant real support in their careers.
Another troubling moment discussed is from Cycle 2 when contestant Shandi Sullivan became heavily intoxicated and engaged in an unwanted sexual encounter. Sullivan later revealed this incident affected her deeply, exacerbating concerns about the show’s treatment of young women. She wanted someone to step in and stop that situation, but no one did.
The show is also known for photoshoots that crossed ethical lines. For example, in one shoot, models posed as crime scene victims; this was insensitive, particularly since one contestant had a family member affected by gun violence. Jay Manuel, a frequent creative contributor, expressed regret over such concepts, stating they overlooked the potential harm caused.
When Banks started facing declining ratings, she was pushed to make changes. Many original judges and mentors were let go, prompting feelings of betrayal among longtime cast members. Miss J, a beloved judge, faced a stroke in 2022, yet he continues to inspire, showing resilience through recovery.
Overall, “America’s Next Top Model” is a complex blend of entertainment and controversy. It reflects both the glamour and the darker realities of the modeling industry, igniting discussions about representation, body image, and mental health. The docuseries compels viewers to consider how far reality TV has come—and how much work still lies ahead.
Source link
Americas Next Top Model,Reality Check: Inside America's Next Top Model,Tyra Banks
