Netflix’s MLB pregame show aimed to elevate the excitement of Opening Day, but viewers had a different experience. Instead of celebrating, many focused on Elle Duncan’s performance during the show.
Duncan appeared alongside baseball stars like Barry Bonds, Albert Pujols, and Anthony Rizzo, along with former football player Jameis Winston. Despite the star-studded lineup, the show felt awkward, and Duncan’s commentary missed the mark for a lot of fans. For example, she mistakenly referred to home plate as “home base,” a slip that immediately annoyed baseball enthusiasts.
Social media lit up with comments questioning why Netflix continues to feature her in key roles. Some fans suggested Lauren Shehadi would be a better fit, noting she was also part of the broadcast but got less airtime. This isn’t the first time Duncan has faced backlash; she previously garnered criticism during Netflix’s coverage of Alex Honnold’s free-solo climb in Taiwan.
This recent drama reflects wider trends in broadcasting, where fans increasingly demand authenticity and deep knowledge about the sports being covered. According to a 2023 survey by Sports Viewer Insights, 78% of sports fans prefer hosts who have a significant background in the sport being discussed, highlighting the importance of expertise over celebrity appeal.
In this landscape, networks are challenged to find the right balance between engaging personalities and skilled commentators. As critics weigh in, it seems Netflix has some work to do in refining its MLB coverage. Moving forward, they might consider prioritizing hosts who resonate more with dedicated baseball fans.
For more insights on sports media trends, check out the latest reports from the Pew Research Center.
