At a preliminary pretrial hearing on Friday, prosecutors argued that 26-year-old Luigi Magione was motivated by anger toward the health insurance industry. They shared various evidence, including body camera footage, surveillance video, phone tracking data, and DNA samples.
Magione has pleaded not guilty to several charges, including first-degree murder committed as an act of terrorism. This charge stems from the killing of Brian Thompson, the CEO of United Healthcare, which took place outside the Hilton Midtown Hotel on December 4.
In New York, first-degree murder is a serious offense, carrying a potential life sentence without the possibility of parole. Prosecutors must show that Magione intended not only to kill Thompson but to instill fear in the broader community. Defense attorney Andrew Alperstein described this as a challenging task for the prosecution.
Magione also faces federal charges that could lead to the death penalty. Alperstein noted that while New York does not enforce capital punishment, the federal government does. The decision on whether to seek death penalties is still pending.
Outside the courthouse, some supporters gathered for Magione. Alperstein pointed out that his case has become a rallying point for those frustrated with the health insurance system. However, he cautioned that this public support could complicate Magione’s defense, as the government aims to send a clear message against violent actions.
The judge has set deadlines for pretrial motions, with the defense required to submit them by April 9 and prosecutors expected to respond by May 14. A ruling on these motions is anticipated on June 26. Magione’s next court appearance is scheduled for March 19 in federal court.
