Battle of the Potato Salads: Which Grocery Store Recipe Reigns Supreme—Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods, or Wegmans?

No summer gathering feels complete without side dishes, and potato salad is a favorite addition. It pairs well with burgers, ribs, or sandwiches. A good potato salad should have a nice mix of flavors and textures.

As barbecue season kicks off, I decided to compare the house-brand potato salads from Wegmans, Trader Joe’s, and Whole Foods. Here’s how they stacked up.

Wegmans: Pricey and Soupy
Wegmans’ potato salad was the most expensive at $5.50 a pound. Its texture was somewhat soupy, with pieces of potato, celery, and pepper flakes in a mayo-heavy mix. The potatoes were mealy, but the celery added a nice crunch, and a hint of sautéed onions gave it a unique flavor. While it had some good elements, the heaviness made it less appealing for a summer barbecue, earning it last place.

Trader Joe’s: Sweet but Soft
Trader Joe’s salad was slightly cheaper at $5 per pound. It looked consistent and had a creamy texture reminiscent of egg salad, with a nice tang. However, it was also the sweetest of the three, which wasn’t a plus for me. The potatoes were a bit mushy, and the celery lacked crunch. Still, I’d pick it up again if I needed a quick side.

Whole Foods: The Clear Winner
Whole Foods’ Red Bliss potato salad stood out as the best. Priced at $4.50 per pound (on sale), it was well-prepared, with fresh ingredients. The salad had vibrant colors with red potato skins and chives. The potatoes were hearty, and the mustard flavor was rich without overwhelming the dish. This salad encapsulated everything a potato salad should be, making it the easy favorite.

A Quick Look at Potato Salad Trends

According to a recent survey by the National Potato Council, potato salad is among the top three side dishes chosen for summer barbecues, highlighting its enduring popularity. More people are now opting for healthier ingredients, such as Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise, reflecting a shift towards lighter options.

In conclusion, for summer gatherings, Whole Foods’ potato salad is the go-to choice, offering quality at a reasonable price. Remember to explore different preferences to find the perfect mix for your next barbecue!

Source link