Beyond Alcatraz: Explore the Controversial U.S. Prisons Trump Is Reopening and Their Impact on Justice

Donald Trump’s recent idea to reopen Alcatraz, a prison that has been closed for over 60 years, grabbed headlines. But Alcatraz isn’t the only infamous prison he wants to bring back to life. The Trump administration is pushing to reopen other closed facilities for detention, even though many were shut down due to safety concerns and mistreatment of inmates.

California lawmakers quickly dismissed the Alcatraz announcement, calling it insincere. However, the plan to revive other troubled prisons is in motion. These efforts involve partnerships with private prison companies, which often face criticism for their practices.

The reopening of closed prisons aims to accommodate immigration detainees, which is different from Trump’s claim that Alcatraz would house “the most ruthless and violent offenders.” In reality, the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is looking to reopen various facilities. For example, they want to revive a prison in California that closed last year, which had previously held over 2,000 people.

In the past, prisons like the Federal Correctional Institution (FCI) in Dublin, California, faced scandals linked to sexual abuse and unsafe living conditions. The facility was shuttered last year amid these concerns. Local officials warn that reopening such facilities would only lead to more injustices. Susan Beaty, a senior attorney for the California Collaborative for Immigrant Justice, noted that expanding detention options typically results in more people being incarcerated, which harms communities.

Meanwhile, in Michigan, a different company plans to reopen the North Lake correctional facility, which could become the largest immigration detention center in the Midwest. This facility has a troubled history, including a hunger strike by detainees in 2020 over claims of mistreatment.

In New Jersey, the Geo Group recently reopened Delaney Hall, facing lawsuits for allegedly failing to meet legal requirements during construction. Newark’s mayor criticized these actions, suggesting they reflect a disregard for the law.

The push to utilize shuttered prisons is just one way ICE is expanding its reach under Trump. Reports suggest that detainees are being moved to facilities meant for other types of inmates, raising concerns about their welfare and the conditions they face. Eunice Cho from the ACLU pointed out that this trend highlights the administration’s willingness to ignore safety hazards associated with these facilities.

Local opposition to prison reopenings is growing. Many community members are becoming aware of how much money is being spent to support these private prison companies. This awareness might lead to increased resistance against more detention centers.

ICE did not respond to inquiries about the reported plans for Alcatraz or other facilities. However, the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) indicated that there’s interest in assessing their needs to support the president’s agenda, which includes reopening Alcatraz.

Experts warn that the conditions in these facilities can be dire. Corene Kendrick from the ACLU dismissed the idea of reopening Alcatraz as impractical, citing its lack of essential services like running water. The situation underscores the ongoing debates about immigration detention in the U.S., which continue to provoke strong reactions and community concerns nationwide.

Check out this related article: Ukrainian Drones Disrupt Moscow’s Major Military Parade, Grounding Flights: What You Need to Know