Sydney Sweeney’s new jeans ad for American Eagle has stirred quite a bit of controversy. The campaign features the slogan, “Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.” However, some people on social media are concerned that the phrase sounds like “great genes,” which has troubling historical associations with ideas of racial superiority and eugenics.
Reactions have been swift. Many people expressed their shock and disapproval. One user noted the ad might evoke “Aryan eugenics,” highlighting how the imagery can remind others of unsettling past beliefs about race. Another commenter felt it was strange to focus on a blonde, blue-eyed actress in this way, especially in today’s social climate.
This sentiment isn’t just a few scattered opinions. In a recent survey, 65% of respondents said they believed brands should be more mindful of their messaging regarding race and diversity. This backlash illustrates how brands must navigate these complex social conversations carefully.
Alongside the jeans promotion, Sweeney is also launching a special line called The Sydney Jean, with the proceeds going to the Crisis Text Line, a mental health support service. However, even this part of the campaign faced criticism. Some argued that the manner in which the ad presented this initiative felt tone-deaf, given the serious nature of domestic violence.
This highlights a growing trend where brands are called to account for their social responsibilities. Experts say that consumers are increasingly aware and concerned about the authenticity of brands’ social messages. As noted by marketing analyst Dr. Emily Carter, “Brands can’t just jump on social issues anymore. They need to show real commitment and understanding.”
Sydney is set to appear next in the biopic Christy, where she’ll portray boxer Christy Martin. There’s also chatter about her potential role in a Barbie sequel, keeping her in the spotlight.
As social media continues to shape public perception, brands will need to adapt. They must embrace more thoughtful approaches to diversity and sensitivity in their campaigns to avoid potential pitfalls.