The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is considering a new reality TV show where immigrants would compete for a chance at U.S. citizenship. A spokesperson noted that the show is still in the early vetting stages and hasn’t been approved or rejected yet.
Producer Rob Worsoff, who pitched the idea, describes it as a "positive love letter to America." He has faced criticism, with some claiming it could exploit participants, but Worsoff counters that no one will be "losing" in the process. His vision is for this show to serve up a heartfelt look at immigrants’ journeys and achievements.
Worsoff, a Canadian immigrant himself, has been trying to bring this concept to life since the Obama administration. While he mentioned having discussions with the current DHS, he stated that Secretary Kristi Noem has not been involved in any talks.
According to DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin, the department fields many TV pitches each year. Each one undergoes scrutiny before any approval is granted. Worsoff believes his show could be as impactful as “The Biggest Loser,” but in a different context. He explained that the goal is not to put anyone down; instead, contestants who are already good candidates for citizenship would get the spotlight. This format could help viewers understand their stories better.
Worsoff shared a glimpse of his show idea, which he’s tentatively titled “The American.” His pitch describes a mix of challenges that would showcase diverse talents and backgrounds. For example, there might be location-themed challenges in San Francisco or New York to highlight American culture.
Social media reactions have varied. Some people criticize the idea, seeing it as a gimmick, while others support it, hoping it will humanize the immigrant experience. Current public sentiment often focuses on the struggles and contributions of immigrants, making this show both timely and contentious.
The proposal indicates that each episode would include not only challenges but also community engagement, like town halls where residents can vote on contestants. "The stakes are definitely real," Worsoff admits, but he feels this keeps viewers engaged and can spark meaningful conversations about what it means to be American.
As debates around immigration continue, the success or failure of this show—and the public’s reception—could reflect broader trends in society. Would it be a celebration of diversity or a problematic portrayal? Only time will tell.
For more on DHS’s ongoing initiatives, you can check their official announcements here.