For years, experts have told us to cut back on red meat and saturated fats. But recent dietary guidelines are shaking things up. They now put a spotlight on protein, dairy, and healthy fats, sparking a blend of reactions among nutrition specialists.
The new food pyramid still encourages eating lots of fruits and veggies and avoiding added sugars. However, it also suggests cooking with butter or beef tallow and increasing protein intake to about 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight. That’s up from the old recommendation of 0.8 grams. You can get this protein from both animal sources like red meat and plant-based options.
Some experts are on board with the focus on cutting out processed foods and reducing sugar. However, there’s concern that promoting more fats could clash with guidelines that say fats shouldn’t make up more than 10% of our daily calories. Plus, many people might not need that extra protein.
“These guidelines show a big change, but they raise just as many questions as they solve,” says Darin Detwiler, a food policy expert at Northeastern University. “I agree with emphasizing real food over ultra-processed options. But I worry about how the science is being interpreted.”
The U.S. Secretary of Agriculture recently stressed, “To Make America Healthy Again,” we must return to basics—whole foods that are nutritious. Less processed food means fewer refined carbs, sugars, and unhealthy additives. This shift could significantly impact Americans’ health, especially as chronic diseases grow linked to poor diets.
Interestingly, the new guidelines are much shorter than before, as Jing-Ke Weng, a biochemist at Northeastern, points out. “This simplification helps people focus on cutting down on processed foods and sugar,” he notes. However, he agrees that encouraging saturated fats like tallow and butter could raise eyebrows.
Detwiler echoes this, highlighting that most Americans already get enough protein. “Higher protein intake might only be beneficial for specific groups, like those into strength training,” he explains. “For the average person, more protein isn’t necessarily better.” Plus, the push for red meat and full-fat dairy seems inconsistent with the advice on limiting saturated fats.
Research indicates that saturated fats can raise LDL cholesterol, a key factor in heart disease. “The guidelines don’t address this risk clearly,” says Detwiler, suggesting that mixed messages about saturated fat can lead people to misunderstand what a heart-healthy diet really is.
The guidelines also remind us to choose foods based on individual needs, which can depend on age and activity level. Janice Maras, a registered dietitian, emphasizes this point. She advocates for focusing on quality, variety, and thoughtful choices rather than sticking to one model. “Protein should vary from animal and plant sources, and dairy needs can differ too,” she says. Understanding food quality and label reading is fundamental to making healthy choices.
In summary, these new guidelines are a step in a fresh direction but come with complexities. As we navigate our diets, it’s crucial to focus on individual needs and make informed choices.
Source link
diet,food,Food and Drug Administration,public health guidelines
