Discover the Top 8 Fast Food Pies: A Sweet Ranking You Can’t Miss – Chowhound

There’s nothing quite like a homemade pie, but fast food chains offer some surprisingly tasty options. They’re quick, portable, and perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth on the go. After trying several pies from popular chains, I’ve ranked them from least to most delicious.

I picked up eight different pies and took them for a taste test. Factors I considered included flavor, texture, filling, and price. Let’s jump into the rankings so you know which pies are worth your time when you need a sweet treat!

8: KFC Cherry Pie Poppers

KFC’s Cherry Pie Poppers are cute little bites, but they didn’t impress me much. Priced at $2.49 for four pieces, they felt a bit pricey for what you get. The dough has a soft texture and lacks the crispiness that would elevate the experience. While the cherry filling is sweet, it lacks real cherry flavor. Overall, they felt cheap and just didn’t cut it compared to other pies.

7: McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie

McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie evokes nostalgia for many, but it missed the mark for me. It’s quite sweet, with a hint of cinnamon in the background, but it relies heavily on sugar. The lattice crust looks nice, but the pie-to-filling ratio is off, leaving it a bit unbalanced. Priced at $2.69, it’s also one of the more expensive options and ranks low on my list.

6: Church’s Texas Chicken Pumpkin Cheesecake Fried Pie

This limited-time pie from Church’s Texas Chicken caught my interest. It’s priced at $1.99, so it’s good on the wallet. However, the filling is underwhelming. You can hardly taste the pumpkin; it’s more like a creamy cheesecake. The crust is fluffy and crispy, which is nice, but there isn’t enough filling to justify a higher ranking.

5: Arby’s Apple Turnover

Arby’s Apple Turnover is more enjoyable. The flaky pastry has a great texture, and it’s priced at about $2.09. While it’s on the messy side, the combination of icing and sweet apple filling offers a satisfying experience. Although it could have used a stronger apple flavor, it’s a solid dessert option.

4: Church’s Texas Chicken Apple Pie

Church’s Texas Chicken Apple Pie is much better than their pumpkin option. For $1.99, you get a made-to-order pie with a better crust and filling ratio. The apple flavor is clear and sweet, with just the right amount of cinnamon. The crispy crust contrasts nicely with the gooey filling, making it a worthy pick.

3: Arby’s Cherry Turnover

This cherry-centric dessert earns a solid third place. The filling has a familiar, comforting taste that reminds me of homemade pies. Pricing around $2.09, the filling and flaky crust create a delightful bite. The icing on top enhances the flavor without overpowering the cherry filling, making it a worthy treat.

2: Popeyes Cinnamon Apple Pie

Popeyes takes the second spot with their Cinnamon Apple Pie, priced at $2.36. The crust is dusted with cinnamon and sugar, adding an extra layer of flavor and crunch. The filling is sweet and robust, though a bit more apple flavor wouldn’t hurt. Regardless, this pie stands out among the competition.

1: Burger King Hershey’s Sundae Pie

Finally, my top pick is Burger King’s Hershey’s Sundae Pie at $2.69. This dessert has layers of smooth chocolate filling in a chocolate crust, topped with whipped cream and chocolate chunks. The texture is creamy and light, reminiscent of a restaurant-quality dessert. I would gladly pay more for this pie because it’s simply that good.

How I Ranked the Pies

I tasted these pies to see how they stacked up. My main focus was on crust and filling. I wanted a good balance, with enough filling to complement the crust. I also took into account the texture and price, although all pies were pretty affordable. After careful tasting and consideration, my rankings represent the best of the best!