Discover Why We’re Skipping This Disappointing Fast Food Chocolate Chip Cookie – A Must-Read Review!

Grace Cary/Getty Images

Fast food and chocolate chip cookies should be a match made in heaven. However, not all cookies are created equal. A recent ranking by Chowhound spotlighted a real dud: the chocolate chip cookie from Jimmy John’s. Instead of being soft and chewy, it was dry and pretty bland, offering only a faint hint of chocolate chip goodness.

Even regular customers are noticing the drop in quality. An employee shared on Reddit that the cookies are no longer the same. Despite being advertised as made with Ghirardelli chocolate chips, the cookie fell flat. If you want a true chocolate chip experience, you might want to whip some up at home instead.

Where to Find Great Chocolate Chip Cookies

Orianna McDavid/Chowhound

While the Jimmy John’s chocolate chip cookie disappoints, there are still plenty of sweet options to explore. Chains like Chick-fil-A, McDonald’s, and Starbucks serve up some tasty treats. Starbucks’ cookie, in particular, has a glowing reputation for being gooey and delightful.

There’s even a wave of home bakers trying to replicate Starbucks’ cookie with popular recipes circulating on social media. Subway also offers cookies, but many find them lackluster. It seems fast food cookie quality can vary widely, leaving us with a hit-or-miss experience.

Jimmy John’s has other options, too, like seasonal treats. For instance, the summer of 2025 brought a Lemon Sunshine cookie that caught some attention. The occasional specialty cookie from fast food places often surprises people, but it’s clear that chocolate chip might not be their focal point.

If you’re in the mood for a chocolate chip cookie, consider checking out local bakeries or even grabbing some store-bought brands that might outshine the fast food version. Not all fast food desserts live up to the hype, but there are definitely some gems to find out there. We’ll be skipping the Jimmy John’s cookie next time around.