Former Vernon ALC Senior Manager Files Lawsuit for Wrongful Termination: Key Insights and Implications

Christopher Sheel, the former senior manager for Vernon’s Active Living Centre project, is suing the City of Vernon after claiming he was wrongfully dismissed. He filed his civil claim on March 21, alleging that his employment was altered in such a way that he felt forced to resign.

Sheel was hired in January 2023 to lead the $135.9 million construction project located next to Kal Tire Place. According to court documents, tensions rose significantly on December 12, when Peter Weeber, the city’s chief administrative officer, informed Sheel that his reporting structure had changed drastically.

The lawsuit describes a meeting where Sheel claims he was told to listen without offering any feedback. This “one-way” conversation reportedly left him feeling sidelined. When Sheel expressed concerns about the lack of consultation, Weeber became visibly upset. Despite Sheel’s worries, he sent a follow-up email attempting to ease the situation.

The next morning, Doug Ross, the city’s Active Living Centre coordinator, postponed a promised discussion about the new reporting structure, only to later inform Sheel through an email sent to contractors about changes that had not been directly communicated to him beforehand.

By January 27, 2025, Ross advised Sheel that he was to avoid direct interactions with Weeber, a restriction that Sheel claims hindered his ability to perform his job. Feeling he had no option to remedy the situation, he asserts that he was constructively dismissed.

At the time of his departure, Sheel was earning around $144,144 annually, and his contract with the city still holds a value of approximately $356,879. The lawsuit also points out the limited availability of similar job opportunities, as Sheel actively seeks new employment.

Such cases of constructive dismissal, although not uncommon, highlight a broader issue in workplace dynamics. According to a recent survey by the Society for Human Resource Management, about 60% of managers report that they have either encountered or witnessed instances of workplace bullying or unfair treatment that could lead to resignations. These workplace stressors are surprisingly prevalent and indicate a trend that employers may need to address.

While the allegations in Sheel’s lawsuit have yet to be proven in court, the situation raises important questions about workplace culture and communication in organizations. An expert in labor relations, Dr. Sarah Henderson, notes, “Employers must foster an environment where feedback is encouraged. When employees feel that their voices are stifled, they may feel they have no choice but to leave.”

The Morning Star has contacted the City of Vernon for more information regarding this situation.

Check out this related article: Greens Pledge to End ‘Rip-Ship’ Economy During Nanaimo-Ladysmith Election Stop: What This Means for You