Critics are not holding back when it comes to Ryan Murphy’s new show, “All’s Fair,” starring Kim Kardashian. Many are calling it “existentially terrible” and a “disaster zone.”
The series follows a team of female divorce lawyers in L.A. as they tackle messy breakups and high-stakes drama. The idea sounds intriguing: these strong women navigate love and money, changing the game along the way. Along with Kardashian, the cast features Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close.
However, early reviews have been harsh. In The Times, Ben Dowell described the show as such a failure that it doesn’t even reach “enjoyably bad.” He argues it presents itself as a feminist tale but ironically celebrates the greed and excess it claims to critique.
Lucy Mangan from the Guardian echoed this sentiment, stating, “I did not know it was still possible to make television this bad.” She feels the show sinks below any acceptable standard and doesn’t seem to understand its own message.
Kardashian’s performance has been a focal point of criticism. Ed Power from The Telegraph noted her lack of charisma and acting chops, suggesting her portrayal of divorce attorney Allura Grant doesn’t inspire confidence. Dowell even compared her acting skills unfavorably to historical figures known for autocratic rule.
Interestingly, this isn’t Kardashian’s first foray into scripted television. She previously appeared in Murphy’s American Horror Story, which also sparked debate about her acting ability. Her role as an executive producer raises questions about what impact she has had on the show’s direction.
Some see “All’s Fair” as reflecting an alarming trend in modern television—a fixation on glam, often highlighted by reality stars. Emily Maddick from Glamour believes the show falls victim to this “Kardashian-ification,” expressing concern about the values it promotes.
Despite all the negativity, discussions are igniting on social media. Fans and critics alike are sharing memes and hot takes, showcasing the show’s unexpected connection to pop culture. This reflects a broader pattern where even poorly received shows can spark community conversations online.
As of now, new episodes of “All’s Fair” are set to stream weekly on Hulu and Disney+. While it’s unclear if its ratings will improve, it’s evident that this series has become a talking point, for better or worse.
For insights about media critiques, you might want to check out a recent report on viewer reception trends, found in Pew Research.
Source link
Kim Kardashian,Ryan Murphy
