This transcript was created using speech recognition software. While it has been reviewed by people, it may have some errors. Please check the episode audio before quoting from this transcript and feel free to reach out with any questions.
My name is Annie Nichol. I’m a writer and an advocate for survivor-centered justice and healing. Many of you might remember my sister, Polly Klaas. She was kidnapped from our home when I was just six years old. Polly was 12 at the time. For two months, her kidnapping turned into a huge national story. News crews stood outside our house every day, and her name filled the headlines. Sadly, the search ended tragically when we learned of her death. Her killer was caught, but that was only the start of the sensationalism.
As I grew up, I noticed something troubling. People told Polly’s story in ways that made her feel unrecognizable to me. True crime isn’t just harmless entertainment. Many people I know enjoy it, but I wish more understood the pain it can cause victims and their families when their stories are exploited for views and clicks.
Polly’s case came at a time when true crime was becoming more popular in the media. Countless books and documentaries have recounted her story and others like it in graphic detail. This booming demand for true crime often overlooks the real harm it does.
I’ve seen how the media’s focus on high-profile cases can lead to harmful policies in our justice system. After Polly’s death, politicians used her name to push tough laws that have only worsened the crisis of mass incarceration. It felt like as true crime became more popular, our focus shifted more towards punishment instead of true justice.
It’s important to know that sensational stories can distort how we view crime. Despite perceptions, crime rates have been declining over the years. Yet, we still implement harsh policies to address these exaggerated fears, creating more harm than good.
Numerous true crime projects have featured Polly’s story, but I’ve rarely been asked for my consent. Recently, some producers reached out, asking for my memories. Those messages often felt manipulative and brought up details I try to avoid for my healing. It was infuriating. These memories are all I have left of Polly that haven’t been exploited.
To truly make a difference, we must listen to survivors’ stories on their own terms. I work with an organization called Crime Survivors for Safety and Justice. We advocate for important changes like trauma recovery centers in vulnerable communities. These initiatives contribute to real safety.
Through my work, I’ve realized that listening to survivors should be a calm experience, not one filled with adrenaline. True listening helps us understand what justice and healing could really look like. If we want to make a real change, we need to approach these stories with care and respect.
