When companies merge or split, taxes can get tricky, especially for employee stock options. Unlike share swaps in tax-neutral mergers, stock options often don’t get similar benefits. This can confuse employees, especially if their options are already vested. Aligning the tax treatment of stock options with share swaps could simplify things for international mergers and acquisitions (M&A).
Typically, mergers and demergers have to go through the High Court and the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) for approval. Under new rules, fast-track mergers enjoy tax neutrality, but fast-track demergers don’t have the same clarity. This inconsistency raises uncertainty and might run counter to the government’s goal of streamlining corporate reorganizations.
A significant question for companies is when to recognize taxability in cases involving earn-outs—payments based on future performance. These payments usually occur only when specific financial targets are met, so it makes sense to tax them in the year they are actually earned.
For domestic mergers, shareholders generally benefit from tax neutrality. However, in cross-border situations involving Indian assets, this isn’t the case. As a result, international reorganizations face disadvantages compared to domestic ones.
Interestingly, foreign shareholders are only taxed in India if they meet certain criteria. In contrast, Indian shareholders face taxes regardless of the deal’s scale. Extending tax neutrality to shareholders would help level the playing field. Additionally, while mergers between companies enjoy some tax benefits, mergers of limited liability partnerships (LLPs) do not, leading to few precedents.
Vaibhav Gupta, a Partner at Dhruva Advisors, emphasizes the need for clarity in these areas. He notes the lack of tax neutrality for partners in LLPs upon conversion into companies, even when the business itself isn’t taxed. By extending these benefits, companies could reduce disputes and provide better tax outcomes for everyone involved.
Overall, it’s crucial to ensure that tax rules support both domestic and international deals, allowing for smoother transitions and less confusion.
Source link
