New Pope XIV Sends Conflicting Signals on LGBTQ+ Issues, Sparking Concerns in the Community

Pope Leo XIV, born Cardinal Robert Prevost, stepped into the spotlight on May 8, 2025. He is the 267th Pope of the Catholic Church, succeeding Pope Francis, who passed away on Easter Monday. Leo XIV’s arrival has stirred curiosity, especially regarding his stance on LGBTQ+ issues.

While he shares Pope Francis’s commitment to the environment, poverty, and migration, past comments raise concerns for some in the LGBTQ+ community. In 2012, Prevost criticized media that he felt sympathized with the “homosexual lifestyle” and the recognition of same-sex families. This has left some wondering if he will uphold the more inclusive policies that Francis began.

Prevost’s guidance during discussions on “Fiducia Supplicans,” which permits blessings for same-sex couples, was not fully supportive. He highlighted the need for national bishops’ conferences to interpret directives – a sign of ambiguity that leaves many uncertain about his view on LGBTQ+ acceptance.

The church’s official stance on LGBTQ+ relationships remains unchanged: same-sex marriage is rejected, and sexual relations between same-sex partners are deemed “intrinsically disordered.” However, Pope Francis attempted to soften this stance through gestures of inclusivity, meeting with LGBTQ+ advocates and promoting compassion within the church.

Sarah Kate Ellis, CEO of GLAAD, mentioned that Francis was a “transformational leader” who sought to include LGBTQ+ individuals in the church. His empathetic approach was a breath of fresh air for many.

In contrast, some conservative church leaders showed resistance to Francis’s outreach, particularly when he allowed blessings for same-sex couples in 2023. Many are now eagerly watching to see how Pope Leo XIV will navigate these sensitive waters.

Prevost, a Chicago native with deep roots in Peru as a missionary and archbishop, breaks a centuries-old convention by being the first American pope. This unique position might play a role in shaping his papacy amidst growing global diversity.

As discussions unfold, the LGBTQ+ community remains hopeful yet cautious about the new pope’s approach. The world is watching how he balances tradition with the need for inclusivity within a changing society.

For more context on this topic, you can check out the report from Pink News.