NGT Imposes Fines on Union Environment Ministry for Delays in Borim Bridge Project: What This Means for Local Communities

Loutolim farmers recently reacted to the National Green Tribunal’s decision to fine the Ministry of Environment, Forests, and Climate Change (MoEFCC). While they welcomed the fine, they remain skeptical about what they see as ongoing delays in resolving the contentious Borim bridge project.

Albert Pinheiro, the president of the Carbot, Mascasana & Bebdo Tenants Association, emphasized the farmers’ commitment to protecting their ancestral lands. “We pointed out to the NGT that the 3D notification issued by MORTH violates Supreme Court orders,” he said. This notification was issued without vital environmental and forest clearances, which, according to him, could result in halting the land acquisition process.

Pinheiro expressed frustration with government tactics that seem aimed at stalling progress. He noted, “They have no defense against our factual and legal submissions.” While the ministry has mentioned revising the project, no official revised plan has been submitted yet.

The core issue centers around whether the project requires environmental clearance, especially due to its size and location on Khazan land, which is designated for agriculture and fisheries. Pinheiro pointed out that even if the bridge were built on stilts, the associated road construction would damage the land.

In a parallel case, the Vanashakti issue has arisen. Pinheiro clarified that while it involves similar environmental concerns, it remains a separate matter. The authorities might be citing this case to justify their stance on environmental clearance, but the application is still pending.

Overall, Pinheiro expressed the farmers’ disappointment at not receiving the interim relief they seek, stating, “Justice delayed feels like justice denied.” Nevertheless, he reaffirmed their commitment to their heritage lands, saying, “Our preparations for cultivation continue, and nothing can disrupt that.”

The farmers are anxious about the extended wait for the next hearing. They worry that authorities might proceed with the project despite ongoing legal challenges. While they stand firm in their beliefs, the uncertainty weighs heavily on them.

Recent statistics underscore the importance of land rights in India. According to a report by the National Coalition for Land Rights, nearly 65% of rural households rely on agriculture. Protecting land rights is crucial not just for these farmers, but for the nation’s food security as well. As debates about development and environmental preservation continue, the Loutolim farmers’ struggle becomes even more relevant.

As we look at this situation, it’s clear that the balance between infrastructure development and environmental preservation weighs heavily on the minds of those in Loutolim. Their fight reflects broader struggles faced by communities across India.

Source link