Nick Castellanos Calls Out ‘Questionable’ Communication with Rob Thomson: What It Means for the Team

Nick Castellanos has transitioned from being the regular right fielder for the Phillies to sharing the role with Max Kepler. Both players have had disappointing seasons in 2025, which has led to this shift. For Castellanos, this change feels particularly significant because he has a longer history with the team.

After the Phillies’ recent win over the Diamondbacks, Castellanos opened up about his feelings. He stated he’s committed to doing whatever it takes to help Philadelphia win a World Series. However, he hinted at some tension with manager Rob Thomson, questioning the praise for Thomson’s way of communicating with players. Castellanos said, “Communication over the years has been questionable.” He reflects on past promises that didn’t match actions, leaving him feeling uncertain.

Their relationship gained attention back in June when Castellanos was benched after an “inappropriate” comment made during a game. This incident ended his streak of 236 consecutive games played. Castellanos admitted that he doesn’t converse much with Thomson, saying, “I play whenever he tells me to play.”

While player-manager disputes are nothing new in baseball, Castellanos’ comments have raised eyebrows. On a positive note, the platoon is showing some success, with Kepler hitting well and Castellanos enjoying a brief hot streak. However, Castellanos still has lower than expected stats this season, with a wRC+ of just 94.

Over four seasons in Philadelphia, Castellanos has generated 1.0 fWAR, which isn’t what the team hoped for when they signed him for $100MM. With $20MM left on his contract for 2026, the Phillies might need to weigh their options, including a possible release.

For now, Castellanos is focused on the playoffs. He remains optimistic and dedicated to helping the team succeed, putting team goals ahead of individual concerns. His attitude reflects a broader sentiment among athletes: the need to prioritize teamwork over personal challenges.

In the larger context, MLB teams often face such player dynamics, and how they manage these relationships can significantly impact performance and team morale. As Castellanos navigates this transition, he exemplifies the ongoing challenges and drama that accompany professional sports.

For insights on player-manager relationships, you might find studies from organizations like the Society for American Baseball Research helpful.

Source link

nick castellanos