Crimson Desert launched yesterday after much anticipation, but the response has been a mixed bag. The game has sold 2 million copies, which is impressive, but the reviews tell a different story. Critics’ opinions vary widely. Some, like Francesco De Meo from Wccftech, enjoyed it, while others were less enthusiastic. Its current Metacritic score is 78, and Steam user reviews, which started at ‘Mixed,’ have shifted to ‘Mostly Positive.’
Controversy arose when the game incorporated Denuvo just one week before launch. Shortly after, players began noticing what seemingly are AI-generated art pieces included in the game—particularly for a historical painting asset.
A Reddit user, Rex_Spy, shared an image that highlights this issue. The artwork is unusual and lacks the detail a skilled artist would typically provide. It’s strange, to say the least, especially if the game’s setting is meant to evoke a sense of realism.
This isn’t the only instance—other players on Reddit have pointed out similar artworks that appear to be AI-generated, missing details that a human artist would typically catch.
Many players are criticizing Pearl Abyss for including these assets without disclosing that GenAI tools were used in their creation. Valve updated its policy in 2024, requiring developers to disclose such information, but the responsibility ultimately falls on the developers to be transparent.
Interestingly, a recent survey showed that most developers agree on the need for these disclosures, yet there’s disagreement on how they should be implemented. Many feel that Valve’s current requirements are insufficient.
As players delve deeper into Crimson Desert, it will be worth watching how Pearl Abyss reacts. Will they adjust the AI-generated assets or add the necessary disclosures? While these artworks may take you out of the experience momentarily, the game offers much more to explore in the open world of Pywell.
The evolving nature of AI in gaming continues to spark debates. As developers experiment with these technologies, the community remains divided. Transparency will be key in maintaining trust and ensuring players feel valued.
