Texas House Approves Bill Mandating Display of Ten Commandments in Every Public School Classroom

The Texas House recently passed Senate Bill 10, which mandates that the Ten Commandments be displayed in every public school classroom. After a last-minute amendment, the bill now heads back to the Senate and then to Governor Greg Abbott, who is expected to sign it into law.

Supporters argue that this gesture reflects America’s moral roots. State Rep. Candy Noble, the bill’s sponsor, claims that the Ten Commandments have historically been part of American education until a 1971 ruling removed them from classrooms. Noble believes that the wording has already been validated by the Supreme Court in a 2005 case regarding a Ten Commandments monument at the Texas State Capitol.

Critics, however, raise serious concerns. State Rep. Vincent Perez argues that placing religious texts in schools can promote one faith over others, violating the First Amendment. He cites the Supreme Court’s earlier ruling in Stone v. Graham, which struck down a similar law in Kentucky, emphasizing that the Court has never allowed mandatory religious displays in public school settings.

The conversation isn’t just limited to Texas. A recent court case in Louisiana, which mirrors this law, has drawn attention. The U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals will hear this challenge, potentially impacting the outcome for similar legislation in Texas.

Many lawmakers and experts believe this bill could trigger lengthy and costly legal battles. For instance, state Rep. John Bryant pointed out that the bill could create confusion among teachers who would struggle to address complex moral questions raised by the Ten Commandments.

In response to the bill, some Democrats proposed amendments suggesting additional religious texts, such as Jewish and Catholic translations of the Commandments, as well as fundamental texts from other faiths like Hinduism and Islam. These amendments were repeatedly dismissed by the Republican majority, leading to claims that the bill promotes a narrow Christian worldview.

Public reaction has been mixed. Some Texas residents support the initiative as a way to reintroduce moral teachings in schools, while others voice concerns that it could alienate students from diverse backgrounds. About one-third of Texans identify as non-Christian or non-Jewish, and many question whether their beliefs should be overshadowed by a religious mandate in public education.

Experts argue that while the desire for moral education is understandable, legislation like SB 10 may not achieve its intended goals. State Rep. James Talarico warned that instead of fostering faith, such measures might produce skepticism or even turn students away from religion entirely.

As this issue unfolds, it will be crucial to watch for further developments in the court system and how Texas residents respond to this controversial measure. The intersection of education, religion, and law continues to shape the modern landscape of American society.

For more information, you can read about the legal context in the Establishment Clause here.

Source link

Education,Education News,News,Politics,Religion,Texas,2025 Texas Legislature,89th Texas Legislature,Establishment Clause,First Amendment,ten commandments,Texas public schools