Toledo, Ohio, is a city rich in culture and flavors. Nestled along the Maumee River, with Lake Erie just a stone’s throw away, Toledo’s culinary scene reflects a blend of traditions and local comforts.
Let’s take a delicious journey through some of Toledo’s favorite foods. Here, you’ll find a range of dishes that locals swear by, perfect for anyone wanting to experience the essence of this Midwestern gem.
1. Tony Packo’s Hungarian Hot Dogs
If you ask a Toledoan about their favorite dish, chances are they’ll mention Tony Packo’s. This iconic spot has been serving up Hungarian hot dogs since 1932. The secret lies in a spicy sausage topped with chili, mustard, and onions that create a perfect flavor burst. Originally popularized on the show MASH*, Tony Packo’s remains a legacy in the city. Try their classic hot dog with everything and explore their other beloved dishes like stuffed cabbage rolls and pierogi.
2. Chili Mac
Chili mac is a beloved local staple, especially in Coney Island-style diners. It features spaghetti or macaroni smothered in rich meat chili, topped with cheese and onions. Humble yet hearty, it’s a favorite among families and workers looking for a quick, satisfying meal. Don’t forget to ask for it “all the way” for the full experience.
3. Toledo-Style Pizza
Toledo’s take on pizza features a unique, medium-thick crust with a sweet tomato sauce and cheese baked all the way to the edge. Original Gino’s, a local favorite since the 1950s, serves pies with a special blend of cheese and toppings beneath. This is not just any pizza; it’s a weekly ritual for many locals.
4. Pierogi and Stuffed Cabbage
Pierogi and stuffed cabbage are delicious reminders of Toledo’s Eastern European roots. These delightful dumplings stuffed with potatoes or cheese, often topped with butter and onions, are a must-try. The same goes for cabbage rolls, slow-cooked in a tangy sauce. You can find them at various family-owned spots.
5. Lake Erie Fish
With its close proximity to Lake Erie, Toledo boasts fresh fish on many menus. Enjoy a platter of lightly breaded yellow perch or walleye, typically served with coleslaw, fries, and a slice of rye bread. During the Lenten season, Friday fish fries attract big crowds, making it a local tradition.
6. Paczki
These eggy, filled doughnuts are popular during Fat Tuesday but can be found at local bakeries year-round. Paczki come in various delightful flavors, including raspberry and custard. Many Toledoans pick them up to share with family or friends, making them a beloved treat.
7. Diner Classics at Schmucker’s
Since 1948, Schmucker’s Restaurant has delighted diners with classic comfort food and homemade pies. Their hot meatloaf sandwiches topped with gravy and tender roast beef plates are local favorites. Don’t skip dessert—try one of their famous pies for the full diners’ experience.
8. Beer Cheese Soup at Maumee Bay Brewing
Located in a historic building, Maumee Bay Brewing Company offers hearty meals paired with their craft beers. The Buckeye Beer Cheese Soup is a crowd-pleaser, often enjoyed with a Reuben sandwich or giant pretzels. It’s the perfect cozy option.
9. Earnest Brew Works
This brewery features a rotating selection of craft beers that locals enjoy. Depending on the location, you might find delicious pizzas or food trucks outside offering tacos and more casual bites. It’s a great spot for a relaxed evening with friends.
10. Date Night in Downtown Toledo
Recent investments have turned downtown Toledo into a vibrant dining destination. You can start the evening at a craft beer taproom, move on to a Mexican restaurant for tacos, and end the night at a cozy wine bar—all within a few blocks. This foodie exploration reflects the diversity of Toledo’s culinary landscape.
Conclusion
Toledo’s food scene is an honest depiction of its culture. You don’t need Michelin stars to appreciate its charm. From Hungarian hot dogs to pierogi and craft beer, each bite tells a story of the city’s heritage and connection to the Great Lakes. Whether you’re visiting or a local, there’s always something delicious waiting for you in Toledo.
