A fascinating prehistoric fossil site has been uncovered in Florida’s Steinhatchee River, dating back around 500,000 years. This incredible Ice Age graveyard is hidden under the water and has revealed over 500 fossils. The findings include remains of giant armadillos, ancient horses, sloths, and possibly a new species of tapir. The site, once a sinkhole, acted like a natural trap for animals during a time known as the Irvingtonian North American Land Mammal Age.

These well-preserved fossils give us a unique look at the animals that lived in North America during a period when fossil records are rare. This discovery could change what we know about how species evolved and how ecosystems changed during the Ice Age.
Robert Sinibaldi and Joseph Branin were the first to find this site while diving in the river in 2022. What began as a few isolated teeth and bones quickly turned into a treasure trove of fossils, prompting the Florida Museum of Natural History to conduct a thorough excavation to explore its importance.
“It wasn’t just quantity, it was quality,” said Sinibaldi, reflecting on the site. “We knew we had an important site, but we didn’t know how important.”
Now, experts at the Florida Museum are carefully studying the fossils to learn more about the Ice Age environment that once thrived in this area.
Of particular interest are fossils from an extinct species known as Holmesina, a giant, armadillo-like animal. Scientists have documented a size increase in this species over time. The discovery at this site helps fill gaps in our understanding of these changes.
“It’s essentially the same animal, but through time it got so much bigger,” explains Rachel Narducci, a vertebrate paleontology collections manager. “The bones changed enough that researchers published it as a different species.”
Fossils of specific bones, such as ankles and feet, show that Holmesina grew larger before its bones fully adapted, challenging previous assumptions that size and anatomical changes happen at the same time.
Another exciting finding is a skull from an ancient tapir, a creature resembling a pig with a short trunk. This skull may represent a new species, as it shows unique features never seen before.
“We need more of the skeleton to firmly figure out what’s going on with this tapir,” cautions Richard Hulbert, the study’s lead author. “It might be a new species, or it could just be an odd individual from a known population.”
Further excavations and analyses are necessary to determine if this tapir indeed represents a new species.
Out of the 552 fossils collected, around 75% belong to an early species of caballine horses, ancestors of today’s domestic horses. This large number of horse fossils suggests Florida’s landscape was vastly different 500,000 years ago.
“For the first time, we had individuals that were complete enough to show us upper teeth, lower teeth, and the front incisors of the same individual,” said Hulbert, noting the exceptional preservation of these fossils.
These horse teeth may help scientists study the diets and habitats of Ice Age horses, providing insights into ancient ecosystems. The prevalence of horse fossils indicates that the Big Bend region of Florida, now forested, was likely an open grassland, ideal for large herbivores. This discovery sheds light on prehistoric climate change and habitat shifts, enhancing our understanding of how ecosystems evolved over time.