Uncovering the Magic: A Captivating Review of The Librarians (2025) | Roger Ebert Insights

A year ago, I couldn’t have imagined that once-solid institutions would crumble so easily under pressure, especially from the Trump administration. Major companies, universities, and media outlets seemed untouchable, but many have bowed to unexpected challenges.

Yet, one group stands strong: school and public librarians. As someone who values libraries, I see them as vital resources for democracy. They champion freedom of thought and provide access to information. Recent interviews and footage from school board meetings show that libraries have turned into battlegrounds. In one community, half of the 40 librarians faced termination or intimidation.

The documentary “The Librarians” dives into these alarming issues, featuring interviews and old footage to paint a vivid picture of the turmoil. It sheds light on the often unwarranted accusations faced by librarians, who are vilified with terms like “pornography” or “grooming” when they try to foster open discussions. Activists behind book bans aim to shield their own children—and all children—from books that challenge their views.

Recently, an anonymous librarian shared a troubling list of 850 books sent by a Texas lawmaker questioning their presence in schools. This list included titles meant to address vital topics like race and identity, raising concerns about censorship.

School librarians are trained professionals who closely consider age appropriateness. They select books based on what suits different maturity levels. For example, a picture book for young children might differ significantly from novels for high schoolers dealing with complex themes.

One book that often gets banned is And Tango Makes Three, about two male penguins raising a chick. It has stirred controversy despite having no explicit content; it simply shows diverse family structures to children. For high school students, the banned titles include everything from historical accounts of the Civil Rights Movement to LGBTQ+ topics.

The documentary shows how these attacks echo darker times in history. It reminds us of book burnings during the Nazi regime and the Red Scare, illustrating that restricting knowledge never ends well. A notable quote from President Eisenhower serves as a warning: “Don’t think you’re going to conceal faults by concealing evidence they ever existed.”

We also hear from voices like Steven Pico, who challenged a ban in the 1970s, taking his fight all the way to the Supreme Court. He stands as a reminder of the importance of standing up against censorship. The film documents how current battles mirror past struggles, with community members voicing their support for access to diverse stories.

The librarians shown in the film aren’t just protectors of books; they believe libraries are gateways to a world of ideas. They face resistance with courage and resilience. One librarian called the librarians’ efforts a “superpower” — the power of research. They know that attacks on libraries are often part of broader efforts against public education.

An intense moment in the documentary features a mother who tried to control what books her children could access. She was confronted by her own son, who shared his experiences as a gay man. This poignant clash illuminates the personal stakes in this heated debate.

This issue isn’t just political—it’s deeply personal. It’s about trust. We need to trust librarians, who provide a balanced view of the world, rather than those who wish to limit access to knowledge. If we confine libraries to safe books only, we risk losing vital discussions about history, science, and human experience.

In these complex times, where misinformation is rampant, the documentary serves as a powerful reminder. As Janet Jackson wisely put it, “We are in a race between education and catastrophe.” We must ensure that libraries remain places of learning, not battlegrounds of censorship.

For more on these critical issues, check out the American Library Association’s resources on book banning and the ongoing fight to protect free access to information.

Source link