Bill McGuire and Roger Hallam raise important points about climate change and the role of scientists (Scientists prize neutrality – that doesn’t cut it anymore). Scientists need to think about how they can use their expertise to inform the public and influence policies on climate issues. Many are already doing this by collaborating with governments and supporting legal actions against polluters.
However, sticking to rigorous, evidence-based science is crucial. If we stray from that, our voices lose weight. One reason scientists hesitate to align with climate activists is that some leaders in the movement have made misleading claims about climate science, which can damage credibility.
For instance, Roger Hallam claimed that climate change could result in 6 billion deaths by 2100. Such statements lack scientific backing. My own experiences at climate activist events show that exaggerations often occur, with many suggesting that significant reports downplay the severity of climate issues.
There’s no need for exaggeration when the evidence is clear. We see the impacts of climate change every day—from devastating floods in Pakistan to droughts in Botswana and wildfires in California. If the climate movement wants scientists’ support, it needs to find a balance between credibility and activism.
Additionally, it’s not just scientists’ neutrality that slows down action against climate change. Universities also lack urgency. These institutions should prioritize climate education across all subjects. A centralized funding model could help make this change, by offsetting tuition for graduates entering fields aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Globally, besides the 9 million scientists mentioned, we have about 25,000 universities and 254 million students. Together, they could form a significant force to combat climate issues. Achieving this requires teamwork and a commitment to prioritizing the planet over short-term interests.
McGuire and Hallam passionately urge scientists to speak out and treat climate change as the emergency it is. Scientists should know they’re not alone; groups like Scientists for Global Responsibility and Scientists for Extinction Rebellion in the UK, as well as Scientist Rebellion globally, are looking for ways to act. There are many opportunities for scientists to contribute and advocate for action against climate change.