Jersey Mike’s Subs is famous for its fresh and tasty sandwiches, but many customers think they have limited options for customization. This misunderstanding often comes from not knowing what toppings are available. In reality, Jersey Mike’s offers a range of choices that can elevate your sandwich game.
One reason some toppings remain unnoticed is the lack of advertising within stores. Customers often default to classic toppings like onions, lettuce, and tomatoes without exploring further. However, if you check the Jersey Mike’s app, you’ll discover a variety of condiments and toppings just waiting to enhance your meal. Many of these options come at no extra cost, while a few may require a small additional payment.
While mustard is a common choice, not everyone realizes there are three types at Jersey Mike’s: yellow, honey, and spicy brown. The spicy brown mustard is a crowd favorite and adds a nice kick to any sandwich.
If you’re looking for some heat, consider adding pickled jalapeños or banana peppers. These can provide a satisfying kick without overpowering the other flavors. For those who want even more spice, the Hot Chopped Pepper Relish is an excellent addition.
For a small fee, you can add bacon or pepperoni to many sandwiches, which can truly enhance the flavor. A newer option is Mike’s Hot Honey, highlighted for its growing popularity. Introduced in early 2025, this sweet and spicy sauce adds a unique twist to your sub for just $0.75.
Customer reviews on platforms like Twitter reflect a growing excitement about these toppings. Many fans share their favorite combinations, showcasing the creativity that exists within the menu.
So, next time you visit Jersey Mike’s, step outside the usual and experiment with these lesser-known toppings. You might just find your new favorite sandwich!
For more detailed insights about Jersey Mike’s offerings, you can read the original article on The Takeout.
Source link
Jersey Mike's Subs, Jersey Mike's locations, sandwich chains

