Unlocking Literacy: Natalie Wexler Challenges Us to Go Beyond the Science of Reading

In recent years, many teachers have adopted the science of reading, changing how young kids learn to read. But a new book raises concerns about this approach. While phonics has become a main part of reading lessons, stagnant test scores indicate that more is needed. Specifically, there’s a need for lessons rich in knowledge, especially in subjects like science and history.

Natalie Wexler, the author of The Knowledge Gap, argues that a focus on detailed content paired with explicit instruction is critical. She believes that a rich curriculum helps students retain information better and builds a solid academic foundation. The more knowledge they gain, the better they can express themselves in writing, creating a positive feedback loop that enhances learning.

Wexler’s latest book, Beyond the Science of Reading, warns that improvements in reading instruction might not fully benefit students if their lessons lack vibrant, engaging content.

In a recent conversation with Greg Toppo from The 74, Wexler discussed the current state of education. She noted that while there are now more knowledge-building curricula available since the publication of her first book, many schools still don’t use them. This slow shift is promising, but it’s not enough. Some people mistakenly think that simply fixing phonics instruction will solve all reading problems, but it’s more complex than that.

Many educators mistakenly believe that children aren’t interested in history or science, often considering these subjects too abstract. Wexler counters that kids can indeed engage with historical topics when presented well. She shared an experience of seeing students captivated by the War of 1812. However, she also pointed out that sometimes teachers misjudge what kids can handle, leading to a disconnect in the classroom.

The idea that students should only engage with material that reflects their own experiences is common, but Wexler argues we should also expose them to diverse perspectives. Engaging with fictional stories can enhance empathy and provide valuable life lessons. A well-told narrative can resonate with students, connecting them to broader themes and experiences beyond their immediate environment.

Wexler also mentioned the challenges educational institutions face due to systemic issues. Many teacher educators have been trained in a way that prioritizes engagement at the expense of actual knowledge. It’s crucial to shift this focus, but it’s a slow process, and teachers need ongoing support to adapt their methods.

When discussing the importance of writing, Wexler emphasized its connection to learning. Well-structured writing exercises can help students process and retain information better. Yet, writing can be tough for students, and without proper guidance, it can become overwhelming. The goal should be to make writing manageable, starting with simple sentences before moving on to more complex tasks.

Finally, Wexler addressed societal pressures regarding educational content. Curricula can face backlash from various groups for different reasons. She believes that compromise is essential in education, ensuring that all students receive a comprehensive learning experience. Understanding that not all content will align with everyone’s preferences can help communities find common ground.

While challenges remain, Wexler sees a growing interest in improving education. More people are recognizing the balance needed between phonics and content knowledge. It’s an ongoing journey, but the potential for positive change is encouraging.

Source link

News,cognitive science,history,Joy Hakim,literacy,Mark Seidenberg,Natalie Wexler,Reading,science,science of reading,social studies,The 74 Interview