In some ways, the proof developed by Jitomirskaya and Avila was a bit underwhelming. They used a method that only worked for specific irrational values, which wasn’t the most elegant solution. It felt like a patchwork quilt, with different pieces stitched together to form the result.
Their proof addressed the conjecture in a simplified model of an electron’s environment. But real-world scenarios are much messier. For instance, the arrangement of atoms in solids is complex, and magnetic fields can vary. Mathematician Simon Becker from the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich pointed out this gap. “You’ve verified it for this one model, but what does that have to do with reality?” he asked.
To apply their findings to more realistic situations, adjustments to the Schrödinger equation were necessary. Unfortunately, as Jitomirskaya noted, this made their proof unreliable in practical contexts. It suggested that the beautiful fractal patterns they uncovered—like Cantor sets and the Hofstadter butterfly—were more curiosities than actual representations of reality.
As time passed, Jitomirskaya and Avila moved on to new challenges. Hofstadter himself expressed skepticism about experimental validation of his butterfly, famously stating he’d be “the most surprised person in the world” if it ever occurred.
Yet, in 2013, a group of physicists at Columbia University managed to capture Hofstadter’s butterfly in a lab. By placing two thin layers of graphene in a magnetic field, they observed quantum fractals in action. Suddenly, what once felt like purely theoretical mathematics transformed into a tangible reality. Jitomirskaya reflected on this shift: “It became very unsettling.”
This experiment highlights a growing trend in physics and mathematics, where abstract concepts are increasingly finding real-world applications. The blend of theory and practice opens doors to new discoveries, creating exciting possibilities for the future of science.
For more in-depth exploration of this topic, consider checking sources like Nature.
Source link
quanta magazine,math,physics,quantum
