Baseball fans will catch the pun right away, but it might take others a moment to get it. In baseball, a non-batting runner trying to “steal” a base can get tagged out. Similarly, in the movie “Caught Stealing,” nobody is literally caught stealing, yet the themes of clever maneuvering and survival shine through.
This film, adapted from Charlie Huston’s 2004 crime novel, is directed by Darren Aronofsky. Known for his bold style, Aronofsky brings a mix of dark humor and energetic storytelling. It’s quite a shift from his previous film, “The Whale,” which was more serious. In “Caught Stealing,” we see the confrontational creativity reminiscent of Aronofsky’s earlier work.
Austin Butler plays Hank, a once-promising baseball star turned bartender struggling with addiction. His regretful journey unfolds through flashbacks that reveal his downfall. His only source of stability is his girlfriend, Yvonne, portrayed by Zoë Kravitz. Yvonne is a paramedic, and her skills come in handy when Hank’s life takes a dangerous turn after he agrees to watch a cat for his unpredictable friend, Russ, played by Matt Smith. This leads to a violent confrontation with Russian thugs.
The violence escalates as Hank faces threats from other characters, including two men with a complex background, cleverly portrayed by Vincent D’Onofrio and Liev Schreiber. Their mother, Bubbe, played by Carol Kane, offers wisdom to Hank, advising him not to show his teeth if he isn’t ready to bite.
One standout character is a New York police officer, played by Regina King. She’s tough and sees through Hank’s facade in a way others can’t. During their conversations, she senses his hidden struggles, hinting at deeper issues tied to his past.
The setting captures the late 90s through period details like Smash Mouth’s “Walkin’ on the Sun” and flip phones. This backdrop evokes a time reminiscent of classic crime stories from authors like Elmore Leonard and films by Quentin Tarantino, filled with unexpected surprises and chaotic energy.
However, a moment in the film left me puzzled. Hank, a likable character we root for, seems to bounce back from a traumatic experience a bit too easily. It’s unclear whether this softens his character or adds to the film’s dark comedy.
Despite its flaws, “Caught Stealing” is an engaging watch. At one point, Hank shows off his baseball skills, impressing a nearby crowd with his swing. The entire film has its own compelling rhythm and charm.
As the story unfolds, it not only entertains but raises questions about resilience and the consequences of our choices. In a world where many seek quick advantages, Hank’s journey serves as a reflection on life’s unpredictability.
For more insights into this film and its connection to New York’s vibrant past, check out The Guardian’s interview with Darren Aronofsky, where he discusses his love for the city and the era it represents.
