Writer-director Ryan Coogler has taken a bold step with his film Sinners. After gaining fame with Fruitvale Station, he found himself deep in franchise work with films like Creed and the Black Panther series. Now, he aims to tell a more personal story, and Sinners gives him the freedom to do just that. Teaming up again with actor Michael B. Jordan, Coogler dives into a fresh genre that blends horror and drama, capturing both the thrill and fear of the unknown.
The film centers around twins Smoke and Stack, both played by Jordan, who return to their Arkansas hometown in the 1930s. They plan to open a juke joint for the local black community. The first part of the film focuses on their preparations, showcasing their charismatic but dangerous personalities as they charm and intimidate their way through town. Jordan skillfully portrays the two brothers with distinct qualities—Smoke is the doer, while Stack is the talker, both exuding a magnetic yet threatening presence.
As the story unfolds, Coogler weaves in deeper themes that resonate today. The twins’ cousin, Sammie, played by R&B artist Miles Caton, dreams of making blues music rather than gospel. His journey highlights the struggle between righteous paths and seductive temptations, echoing the film’s broader theme of the deals we make with darker forces in life. Coogler’s exploration of black entrepreneurship against the backdrop of historical oppression feels relevant and poignant amid rising conversations about systemic racism and gentrification.
The film doesn’t shy away from addressing these issues. Smoke and Stack purchase a former mill from a white man, who downplays local KKK rumors. This highlights the danger that lurks beneath the surface, mirrored by the arrival of Remmick, an Irish-American character played by Jack O’Connell. Remmick represents the invasive threat encroaching on the brothers’ dreams, adding intensity and conflict as the film progresses.
Coogler’s experienced team—including editor Michael P. Shawver and production designer Hannah Beachler—ensures that Sinners is visually captivating, with blues music driving much of the energy. However, the film sometimes struggles to carve out a unique identity. It borrows stylistic elements from genre giants like Quentin Tarantino and Jordan Peele, which could dilute its originality.
Despite its predictability in some storytelling aspects, the film offers plenty of thrills. Once it leaves the slow setup behind, it delivers exhilarating moments filled with tension, bloodshed, and genuine jump scares. The cast brings their A-game, especially Wunmi Mosaku and Delroy Lindo, who inject vibrancy into the narrative.
Overall, while Sinners has enjoyable moments and an engaging story rooted in history and culture, it walks a fine line between homage and innovation. The film seems caught between wanting to push boundaries and play it safe, resulting in a crowd-pleaser that could have left a deeper mark.
For more insights on how film reflects societal issues, you can check out this Pew Research report on media influence.