Trump’s Gulf Visit: Celebrating Deals Amid Skepticism
Last week, President Trump touted his four-day trip to the Gulf as a historic success. He visited Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and the UAE, proudly claiming he secured over $2 trillion in investments during his tour.
The trip was a spectacle, featuring fighter jets, car parades, and lavish ceremonies. The UAE even awarded Trump its highest civilian honor. This grand display highlighted the Gulf states’ wealth and desire to strengthen ties with the U.S.
Trump’s main goal was clear: attract billions in investments. In Saudi Arabia, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman emphasized a $600 billion commitment to U.S. partnerships, with deals covering areas like arms sales, healthcare, and technology. Notably, a $142 billion defense deal emerged as the largest arms transaction ever reported.
However, skepticism looms. Historical context shows that while Trump announced $450 billion worth of deals during his first term, actual transactions between 2017 and 2020 fell short at under $300 billion according to the Arab Gulf States Institute.
Tim Callen, former IMF mission chief to Saudi Arabia, expressed caution. “The proof with all these deals will be in the pudding,” he noted, highlighting the difference between announcements and tangible outcomes.
In Qatar, Trump claimed a staggering $1.2 trillion in economic exchanges, yet only $243.5 billion was detailed in the official fact sheet. One confirmed deal was Qatar Airways slated to buy 210 jets from Boeing, which could potentially support 154,000 American jobs annually.
Despite grand announcements, challenges exist. Oil prices, which recently hit a four-year low, put pressure on oil-dependent economies like Saudi Arabia. The IMF has even revised its growth forecast for the kingdom. Callen warns that current oil market conditions make it “very hard for Saudi to come up with that sort of money.”
Analysts also point out that many agreements signed during the trip were non-binding. For instance, 34 agreements worth $90 billion announced by Saudi Aramco lack clear financial commitments. Critics note that some deals were previously disclosed, raising doubts about their novelty and impact.
The evolving U.S.-Gulf relationship marks a shift from traditional oil-for-security arrangements towards economic collaborations. Bader Al Saif from Kuwait University highlights that the AI deals between the U.S. and Gulf states reflect plans for a future where technology plays a central role in strengthening ties.
With both sides eager to showcase their partnership, reactions range from enthusiasm to skepticism. Trump aims to use these deals as evidence of his economic successes. However, many await to see if they translate into real benefits.
In a dynamic geopolitical landscape, the next steps form the crux of this budding partnership. As Trump enjoys his moment, the future may hold unexpected twists, with both partners looking to assert their roles on the global stage.
For further context on U.S.-Gulf relations, consider reading reports from the Arab Gulf States Institute.