Unveiling ‘Conclave’: What the Movie Got Right and Wrong About Real-Life Papal Elections

Speculation about who will be the next pope often draws significant attention, especially around a conclave—a process steeped in centuries-old traditions. The upcoming conclave to elect a new pope following the death of Pope Francis has heightened interest, fueled by Hollywood’s latest portrayal in the film "Conclave."

The film, a 2024 political thriller, captures the intricacies of the conclave. It introduces many to the selection process with its mix of ceremony and drama, albeit with a distinct cinematic flair. While some critics argue it takes liberties with the truth, it highlights real issues the Catholic Church currently faces, marrying fact with fiction in an engaging manner.

Experts agree that "Conclave" gets several elements right but points out some inaccuracies.

Authenticity of Visuals

The movie does a great job recreating the setting of the Vatican and the conclave itself. "The film accurately captures the aesthetics of the Vatican," notes William Cavanaugh, a professor at DePaul University in Chicago. He emphasizes that the scenes depicting the pre-conclave discussions among the cardinals hold true to reality.

However, some details, such as the color of the cardinals’ garments, are not depicted correctly. Rev. Thomas Reese, a Vatican expert, points out that while the film’s visuals are impressive, the red of the garments looks overly vibrant compared to the actual shade worn by cardinals.

Speed of the Conclave

The movie correctly aligns with expectations surrounding the conclave’s timeline. Massimo Faggioli, a theological history professor at Villanova University, mentions that a lengthy conclave can indicate division within the Church. Historically, recent conclaves have tended to conclude quickly, reflecting a united front.

Errors in Detail

Yet, "Conclave" does make notable missteps. For instance, the inclusion of a cardinal named in secret (in pectore) attending the conclave is highly unlikely. Reese explains that this tradition requires public acknowledgment from the pope for legitimacy.

Moreover, the film’s portrayal of cardinals taking turns revealing confessions is misleading and violates key Church laws. Such dramatic liberties may serve the narrative but undermine significant aspects of the Catholic faith.

User Reactions and Social Media Buzz

The film has sparked conversations across social media. Many users share their excitement, analyzing various plot twists and debating how closely the film mirrors reality. Discussions also highlight a mix of curiosity and skepticism, as fans express interest in the real-world implications of a new papal election.

Conclusion

In summary, "Conclave" succeeds in captivating audiences with its dramatic representation but does not fully encapsulate the nuances of the papal selection process. As the Catholic Church approaches this pivotal moment, the film serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between tradition and modernity.

For more insights on the process and its implications, read this article on the Catholic Church’s conclaves.

Source link

Pope Francis, General news, National, William Cavanaugh, Voting, World news, Jorge Mario, Religion, Roman Catholicism, Thomas Reese, Massimo Faggioli, United States government, Conservatism, Kabul, Kurt Martens, Arts and entertainment, Entertainment, World News