There’s trouble brewing in France regarding environmental and health protection agencies, like ANSES, ADEME, and OFB. These organizations are under fire, facing attacks that vary in intensity. Some political groups are fanning the flames, hoping to take advantage of farmers’ frustrations. Even government members sometimes seem unable to address the challenges these farmers face.
The nature of the criticism is alarming. Misinformation spreads easily on social media, trying to tarnish the reputation of these agencies and their employees. People question the integrity of those working hard to enforce regulations, sometimes without any consequences for those spreading falsehoods. Meanwhile, suggestions for reforms often aim to reduce the agencies’ independence or effectiveness, relying on misleading claims.
As tensions rise, some agricultural movements have reacted more aggressively than is warranted for peaceful protest. A few members claim that public inspectors are overstepping, suggesting they are too harsh during their evaluations. While occasional misconduct is unacceptable, it represents only a small part of the agencies’ daily work.
This situation leads to a troubling pattern. Politicians sometimes echo exaggerated claims from agricultural unions, using isolated incidents to paint a broader narrative that discredits these agencies. Such actions put the very frameworks that protect our environment and health at risk.
The rule of law must be upheld consistently. It’s vital that we defend both law enforcement and the agencies that carry out regulations set by Parliament. Undermining the authority of these institutions, especially those protecting our environment, is dangerous. It threatens our democracy and weakens the very structures that keep it standing.
Additionally, there’s a worrying push for deregulation, reminiscent of movements in the US and Argentina. Some advocates argue that cutting back on environmental regulations will save money. This approach is misleading and harmful. While scrutinizing public spending is important, it shouldn’t turn into an attack on those enforcing necessary laws. Investing in health and environmental safety is crucial, and the benefits far outweigh the costs.
Ultimately, protecting our environment and public health should remain a priority. Challenges exist, but tearing down the institutions meant to help us navigate these issues is not the way forward.
Translation of an original article published in French on lemonde.fr;
