Urgent Study Reveals: Carbon Dioxide Removal Techniques May Lead to Ocean Oxygen Crisis

A recent study in Environmental Research Letters raises important questions about the impact of marine carbon dioxide removal (mCDR) techniques on ocean oxygen levels. Led by Prof. Dr. Andreas Oschlies from the GEOMAR Helmholtz Center for Ocean Research Kiel, this research highlights a crucial problem: while some mCDR methods could help combat climate change, they may also worsen ocean deoxygenation, harming marine ecosystems.

The State of Ocean Oxygen

The ocean has lost about 2% of its oxygen over the past few decades, and this trend worsens with climate change. As temperatures rise, marine life is facing more challenges. Unfortunately, some climate solutions might actually contribute to this oxygen depletion. Prof. Dr. Oschlies and his team used global models to better understand these impacts.

Risks of Marine Carbon Dioxide Removal Techniques

mCDR methods aim to boost the ocean’s ability to absorb carbon. However, not all of them are beneficial. Some biological methods, like ocean fertilization and macroalgae farming, may increase oxygen consumption. The study suggests that decomposition processes following biomass production can significantly reduce oxygen levels. Prof. Dr. Oschlies sums it up well: “What helps the climate is not automatically good for the ocean.”

The Depletion from Biological Methods

Many biotic mCDR techniques could worsen oxygen loss. The study estimates that their oxygen consumption could be 4 to 40 times greater than any potential gains from reducing CO2 emissions. This emphasizes a critical need for careful evaluation of climate solutions to prevent further degradation of ocean health.

Geochemical Methods: A Different Approach?

On the other hand, geochemical mCDR methods, such as enhancing ocean alkalinity using limestone, show less impact on oxygen levels. These approaches do not add nutrients that could lead to oxygen loss. Their effect on ocean oxygen is similar to simply reducing CO2 emissions. However, experts note that the scalability and long-term viability of these methods still need thorough investigation.

Large-Scale Macroalgae Farming: A Silver Lining?

One promising method is large-scale macroalgae farming, particularly with biomass harvesting. This could actually improve ocean oxygen levels instead of depleting them. By removing excess nutrients and biomass, this approach might help reverse some oxygen losses from climate change. Simulations suggest it could restore up to 10 times the oxygen lost over the past century.

Conclusion

The tension between fighting climate change and protecting ocean health is evident. As Prof. Dr. Oschlies pointed out, solutions need to be comprehensive. The study urges a re-evaluation of marine carbon dioxide removal methods to ensure we do not compromise ocean ecosystems in the process.

Understanding these dynamics is crucial for securing a healthier ocean. As we look for solutions, focusing on methods that support both climate and marine life can lead to better outcomes for everyone.

For a deeper dive into this critical issue, check out the findings in the full study at Environmental Research Letters.

Source link