Food coloring has always sparked interest, especially among those who love bright, vivid snacks. At the forefront of this change is Sam’s Club, where Nick Scheidler and his team are leading the charge to replace artificial colors with natural ones. Starting in 2022, they set a goal to eliminate many artificial ingredients from their Member’s Mark brand by the end of the year.
Colorful snacks can be tricky. Scheidler admits, “Color has been a challenge for us.” Major food brands like Kraft Heinz and Nestlé are also rethinking their use of synthetic dyes, pressured by shifts in consumer preferences and health concerns.
Natural dyes come from sources like beets, turmeric, and spirulina. However, using these alternatives isn’t straightforward. Natural colors can fade or require significantly more concentration to achieve the same vibrancy. For instance, to get a bright hue in frosted cookies, it took 30 times more natural dye than synthetic dye.
This push for change isn’t just corporate responsibility. Recent statistics show that synthetic food dyes are found in nearly 20% of packaged foods, especially those targeting children. Experts like Marion Nestle note that brighter colors often lead people to believe that food tastes better, long before they even take a bite. The influence of marketing has conditioned us to expect vibrant colors in our food.
In the past, General Mills faced backlash when they switched Trix cereal to natural dyes, resulting in a duller product. Consumers responded negatively, prompting the company to revert to artificial dyes. This event underscored the importance of color in food marketing and consumer expectations. Studies show that children, in particular, are drawn to colorful food, making their preferences a vital focus for brands.
The approach to color in food has evolved. Marketing and the rise of processed foods have trained consumers to expect a certain aesthetic. As food historian Ai Hisano states, the competitive landscape has influenced what colors we see in our food. The vibrant hues we now associate with snacks are not just about taste; they’re about visual appeal, influenced by years of advertising.
As Sam’s Club nears its goal of eliminating artificial colors, it continues to survey shoppers, and the feedback is clear: color is crucial. Despite the challenges in achieving natural vibrancy, consumers still seek that bright aesthetic in their snacks and drinks.
The ongoing transformation in the food industry reflects a growing desire for healthier options without sacrificing the appeal of color. As consumers become more health-conscious, it is essential to balance nutrition with the visual excitement that colorful foods provide.
For more information on food coloring trends and health implications, check out this report from the [Center for Science in the Public Interest](https://cspinet.org/), which advocates for safer food policies.

















