Why India is Facing Challenges in Delivering Cash to Carbon Credit Producers: An In-Depth Analysis

Verification delays are affecting carbon credit payments, and middlemen are taking a big cut. This leaves farmers like Jitendra Singh with little to show for their efforts. Singh changed his rice farming methods in Haryana to reduce methane emissions and hoped to earn from carbon credits. Three years have passed, and he hasn’t received anything.

Carbon credits allow companies to pay for projects that capture carbon, helping businesses appear eco-friendly. While large corporations pour billions into these credits, the system is struggling. Reports show that many credits are “phantom credits” that don’t lead to real carbon reductions. In 2021, the market thrived at about $2 billion but plummeted to just $723 million in 2023.

This decline raised concerns about the credibility of carbon projects, causing delays in approvals. Singh said, “It will happen when it happens,” highlighting the frustration farmers face.

Despite India having 60% of its land used for farming and generating 20% of the world’s carbon credits, most funds end up in the pockets of middlemen. The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) reported that the money earned from carbon credits often fails to reach the farmers who need it. Experts warn that the current system only benefits project developers and auditors, leaving communities without a fair share.

Trishant Dev, a carbon market expert, emphasized that farmers aren’t getting enough compensation to change their practices. PVS Suryakumar, a former bank executive, noted the greed present in the voluntary carbon market, where intermediaries rush to profit from farmers. The delay in project approvals and the complexity of enrolling farmers in the market can take up to two years.

– Farmers need better compensation for sustainable practices.

– Regulation must improve to protect community interests.

– Transparency in the process is critical for market confidence.

As these challenges become more apparent, calls for stricter regulations are growing. Suryakumar argues for uniform standards to ensure communities benefit. The Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) has stepped in to tackle these issues, establishing new standards for carbon credit certification. However, about one-third of existing credits fail to meet these criteria, raising further concerns.

India plans to create its own carbon credit market to enhance the verification process and support farmers directly. Ritu Bharadwaj from the International Institute for Environment and Development highlighted the importance of ensuring that monitoring processes are accessible and affordable for farmers. The goal is to increase transparency, allowing farmers to benefit more from their sustainable efforts. Solutions include using smartphone technology for data collection and forming cooperatives to strengthen farmers’ market positions.

The hope is that these steps will help unlock India’s potential for carbon credits and make a real difference in combating climate change.

Source link